I bought this blindly after reading the previous reviews (really need to get out more and test the perfume first),if I'd tested it in a shop I definately wouldn't have bought it.
The intitial smell after spraying appears to be slightly menthol, imagine cough sweets but in a bottle, especially Tunes. It's also very sweet. However fast forward an hour and you have quite a nice sutble scent (no more Tunes or menthol).
I've given this a three, though it would have been three and a half if the option had been available, because of the wait and the fact I wouldn't have the confidence to spray and go out immediately. The scent lasts well over the course of the day and the bottle is absolutely gorgeous and looks expensive. Over all, after the menthol pong has gone it is a lovely perfume, probably aimed at the younger end of the market but still good for the older (like me).