Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
5 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A good introduction to the Country, 11 Sep 2005
The Koreans is a brilliant book about the character of the Korean people, and how they came to be that way. Korea is a fascinating country, full of contrasts that can delight or infuriate a foreigner. I definitely fall in the former group. I lived in Gumi, north of Daegu, for a year in 2001/2002 working as an ESL teacher. US military personnel aside, probably the majority of foreigners in Korea find themselves in this profession. I didn't read this book until well after I left, and I wish I had read it before I went to Korea in the first place. Anyone who has lived in Korea for any length of time (the author, Michael Breen, has lived in Seoul for many years) will find themselves nodding in agreement with many of Breen's experiences, and his explanation of them. Amongst other things Breen talks about the drinking habits, queue jumping, and the very bad driving that prevails the country, in a humorous and informative manner. He also discusses the conglomerates, the "company life" and the all important concept of saving face, in a country steeped in Confucian values. The love he has for his adopted country shines through the written text. As well as serving as a social commentary on Korea, The Koreans also acts as a potted history of this turbulent county, which it needs to be to explain the Korean psyche. Korea has risen from a predominantly agricultural society at the time of the Korean War, to a modern day superpower, at the forefront of technological innovation. The Koreans discusses the rise of Korea from the ashes of the war to the bustling powerhouse it is today. It doesn't neglect more ancient history if it relates to a key discussion point - for example, Breen discusses the creation of the Hangul alphabet, a system of writing formed hundreds of years ago by a Korean king, which has ensured that the literacy rates of the general population are well above the world average. It is surprising just how much pride Koreans take in their written language even today. However, it has to be said that "The Koreans" is no substitute for a proper history of the country - try "The Two Koreas" if that is your interest. First published in 1999, The Koreans has been updated to take into account some of the key developments on the Korean peninsular, particularly the ever so slightly warming of the South Korea/North Korea relationship, with South Korean conglomerates beginning to invest in North Korean ventures (although the more cynical of observers speculate this has more to do with a North Korean need for cash in its cash strapped economy than a genuine desire for reconciliation). The South Korean/North Korean relationship is debated at some length. Another key development since the first edition was of course the joint staging with Japan of the 2002 FIFA Football (Soccer) World Cup. The fervent passion shown by the Koreans, many of whom will have never shown any interest in the sport, helped propel their national team the Red Devils into a World Cup semi-final showdown with Germany, which they sadly lost. The whole month of June 2002, while the tournament absorbed the whole of Korea, is probably my personal highlight of my time in Korea. I recall vividly cheering on Korea in the round of 16 match against Italy amongst several Koreans gathered around a TV setup outside a 24/7 shop whilst eating watermelons that a seller passed around. If you want to learn anything about Korea, this should be your first port of call. I particularly recommend it to all those seeking jobs in Korea as prospective ESL teachers as it will help your understanding in dealing with the people, but anyone intending to stay a while will get just as much out of it.
|
|
|
5 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
A stepping stone to discovering Korea... but no more., 2 Aug 2004
Having recently arrived to live and work in S. Korea, I found Breen's book very helpful in giving me a general overview of the country and its people. Breen has obviously spent a lot of time here and a lot of that mixing with some key people that have made S. Korea what it is today. But there are several areas which weaken Breen's work. The main weakness of this book lies in the fact that Breen is covering the entire history and makeup of a people in a mere 250 pages. Surely, for 15 years in the country, Breen can do better than that. As a consequence of this, Breen covers events and culture at a very fast pace. Despite my lack of detailed knowledge of Korea, I got the feeling that there was a risk of some generalisations being made here. If anyone were to rely on this book and, having read it, claim insight into Korea, I would take their claims very lightly indeed. The style is quite informal - too much so for me at times - and I came away from it yearning for more; more detail, more history, more views of people in the lower echelons of society and more insight into N. Korea, which despite the all-encompassing title, seemed to play second fiddle to the South where modern history was concerned. So, I'd recommend this as a general introduction but caution readers to treat it merely as a stepping stone to more detailed reading and your own experiences with this fascinating country.
|
|
|
0 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Appropriately out-dated., 15 Sep 2007
On reading this book I was quite put off even thinking about visiting South Korea and meeting its introverted,superstitious, guilt-ridden, xenophobic, irrational, atavistic, naive and rice-economy minded peasant population. Or rather it would have put me off had I not been here for six years already.
Given the rapid pace of economic and social change over the last 20-30 years I'm sure that Breen will appreciate the view that much of the criticism contained in his book has obsolescence built into it having been in print for ten years now.
However he is right about many things that still pertain especially the corruption, insularity (a general Asian trait I contend) and appalling standard of driving ; there is not a red light bright enough to be stopped at or obstacle so small that it can't be over come by the hysterical application of four-way flashers, no wonder that there is slaughter on the roads.
How far reforms in governance, financial institutions ,undemanding University under-graduate courses and the all pervasive bribery culture have come along can be more accurately told by bods better informed than myself but as I write the Korean Stock Exchange is still classed, by the FTSE, as only an 'advanced emerging exchange' rather than 'advanced, a classification coveted by KRX. This is mainly due to foreign exchange restrictions an the inaccessability of the Korean market to global investors.
That said, don't let the book put you off coming to Korea. As Breen intimates, if you are well behaved and courteous it will be appreciated. Koreans have a good sense of humour and appreciate it in others.
I do agree though that although Korea's success is admirable its peasant-confucian mindset has militated against it achieving even greater things. And if it realy wants a seat at the international top table it will have to accept western standards of laissez-faire economy, business law, and rationalism.
(Michael Breen is a contributor to The Korea Times)
|
|
|
|