Despite having all the makings of a great musical and overshadowing the much more enjoyable 'straight' Ronald Colman version, this is less than the gem it should be. The story is an ideal peg on which to hang a musical, but aside from the standout numbers the score is not always as strong as it could be and, at times, fails to energise the film - too many of the songs slow it down rather than driving it along.
Howard Keel has a ball as the street-corner poet who, through a combination of lies and luck, finds himself veering between power and prison, always landing on his feet with his pockets full. Yet it is hard to escape the feeling that he is fighting to keep the picture's spirits up while everyone else is on the verge of giving up. The casting is at times esoteric, especially when one sees such well-known Arab actors as Mike Mazurki, Jay C. Flippen and Jack Elam, but the fault seems to lie more behind the camera than in front of it. Although a lot of money obviously went into the production design, Minnelli's direction is unduly restrained and lacking in imagination (Dolores Gray's first number is particularly static and unenthusiastic) and could sorely use some of Keel's bravado.
Warner Home Video's US Region 1 NTSC DVD offers a fine package, though, with a good looking widescreen transfer, deleted musical number Rahadlakum, an audio outtake of Rhymes Have I, the trailer for this and the Colman version, two promotional extracts from The MGM Parade, cartoon The First Bad Man and Oscar-nominated CinemaScope short The Battle of Gettysburg.