Most Helpful Customer Reviews
4.0 out of 5 stars
Very Good Read!, 25 Dec 2007
This review is from: Kinslayer Wars (Elven Nations) (Mass Market Paperback)
This is a most useful insight into the background of the psyche of the elves on Krynn, and the fundamental differences between Silvanesti, Kagonesti and Qualinesti. One should read all three of the novels.
At times, the pace is a bit slow and there are quite a great number of spelling mistakes - which tend to distract from the flow.
The whole tale is a lesson in patience and ruling well. There are some very profound issues explored - not the least of which is race, but also family, the wreckage that fate can have, the strange ways of desire and the whole notion of being outcast.
I thnk there needs to be a follow up trilogy to this one, in the sense, now of filling in some of the missing ancient history details connecting this series with the people referred to in the Elven Exiles (mainly the ancient Mages).
This series is well worth reading. I recommend it as an important part of Krynn's Ancient History.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Not the war I expected, in a good way., 19 Sep 2006
By Bret Sheeley "carteeg" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Kinslayer Wars (Elven Nations) (Mass Market Paperback)
After reading about 50 Dragonlance novels/anthologies, I finally came to reading 'Elven Nations'. I had always heard how the Kinslayer Wars divided the elven nation in two. I had always thought it was a civil war, and after reading this wonderfully constructed tale I see how much more of an odd affair the schism truly was.
As the war with Ergoth continues, some elves sided with the human nation. Although the dwarves were an important factor, the action of the primarily human vs. elven nations fighting was engaging enough to hold my interests. However the separation of Kith-Kanan from Sithas was always the main point of this trilogy. Yet it felt like is was a sort of 'B' story to the war. Funny enough, I think that by Niles hitting only on those details when he needed to, the reader gets the sense of how quiet and how without much debate did these twins come to see the world in different ways and in the end have to part company for good, separating the nation in the process.
It wasn't a separation due directly to war. It was one caused by quiet frustrations slowly building and festering as decades wore on. This so-called 'B' story had no major climax, just a few points of epiphany involving lumps in the characters' stomachs which the readers can see developing. It was a vastly different route than what I expected, and I was extremely glad I was able to see something beyond a direct conflict of words and blows. There is enough enjoyment of that sort coming out of the Ergoth/Silvanesti conflict. But the more important story, the seeming 'B' story, is probably what I will remember more.
I know the story is 15 years old now, but I give credit and thanks to Mr. Niles for putting this great addition to the Dragonlance history together.
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
One of the reasons I got back into Fantasy!, 6 Jan 2004
By Lisa - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Kinslayer Wars (Dragonlance) (Paperback)
This, being the second book of a trilogy, isn't really the book that got me back into reading fantasy works but, it IS the one that kept me here! Douglas Niles makes his characters so flawed, so real that I find myself staying up way too late reading, waking up late for work and repeating the whole process day after day until I complete the book! My only regret is that Niles nor any one else has continued the story. (From the immediate end of Volume 3 of the trilogy)
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Depressing, yet enjoyable, 23 Nov 2002
By D. Pachal - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Kinslayer Wars (Dragonlance) (Paperback)
"The Kinslayer Wars", but Douglas Niles is probably one of the better Dragonlance books out there. It has its share of action and adventure. Though, as the story nears its end, Niles seems to kill off characters just to keep the plot moving. Granted, it represents actions that needed to take place, yet many of the deaths seem to be unjustified. But, all in all, this book is enjoyable to read, albeit a little depressing towards the end. It has a lot of action, much of the book centering around pivitol battles and situations during the Kinslayer Wars. This book isn't that long, only about 300 or so pages so it is a quick read. If you want to learn more about the Elven past, this book and series is what you need. It reveals pivitol information that deals with the seperation of the Silvanesti elves, and the reasons for Kith-Kanan's ideas of founding a new nation for himself, the Qualinesti. If you can get a hold of this book or series, check it out. It is worth the read.
|
|
|