Without futilely wasting words on one of the most overstudied pieces in the most overstudied literary canon, "King Lear" is staggering. I know a great many who prefer, say, "Hamlet", but, unlike that nebulous stuff, this is the guts. "[I]nnocent frail man" is too cowardly to face it and literature generally serves, to varying degree, some form of illusion or another to feed man's escapist appetite. Admittedly, Shakespeare, as usual, does not keep you interested dramatically, be it by using plot, intrigue or imagination, but the profoundness of the poetry of "Lear" certainly manages to sustain my rapt for VERY NEARLY the entire length of the play. It is just so rare to encounter so absolute a chivalric statement of the intrinsic nothingness of everything. Shakespeare had written in "Hamlet" that nothing is good or bad except man's thinking makes it so; "Lear" expands the net of the conceptual backbone of this notion and illustrates it.
The editor's ideology in this New Swan Shakespeare Advanced Series edition is to create an edition of "King Lear" which concentrates on explaining the text of the play, letting it present itself so that the student on his own may find enjoyment thereof on the play's own merit. The notes are thus congenially printed on pages facing the text and limits themselves to addressing linguistic difficulties; contextual, textual and interpretative issues are discussed minimally and only when it would seem absolutely necessary to do so. There is also a glossary of Shakespeare's vocabulary to assist the modern reader generally. From personal judgement, though it is only contingent, the text appears conservatively modernized - the `it', for instance, is retained as a possessive adjective whenever it occurs. There is a good but not in any way expansive introduction providing the basics of the historical and critical background to the play. Given its age, this edition would be considered dated in scholarly circle, especially since it collates both the quarto and Folio texts which are now held to be separate variants of the play. It should be argued, however, that familiarizing oneself with the text first is the most important thing. For in the real world of performance directors will use newly edited scripts drawn from whatever has survived for the particular productions without so much as the slightest regard for the raison d'être of the extant variants whilst in the academic world - of habitually reading beyond what was ever written and minutely scrupulously - anything at all could only be made of the several versions after the text has been thoroughly learnt.
The type size is probably just a little too small. But the layout is neat and easy to read. The text is marked wherever an explanatory note accompanies it and the notes are posited just a roll of the eyeballs away from what they explain, saving the reader that disruptive annoyance of having to interrupt the reading only to find there to be no note to compensate for it. Overall it probably falls just short of the Arden series in terms of attractiveness. For the general readers, the students and the stage professionals seeking to conceive a production of "King Lear" that is as empathized, fresh and pertinent to our culture as possible, there is no deficiency to detract from this edition.