Tim O'Brien is an excellent writer who, when on song, can really knock your socks off. July, July isn't his worst offering by any means, but it isn't his best either.
Of the individual short stories (for July, July is a novel made of individual short stories) some were excellent, some were merely good, all were written with the author's customary verve, pathos and an assured technique which can create humour.
The reunion itself didn't seem to go anywhere or resolve much, the characters just seemed to fizzle out in the same way they were going before but at least the short stories let you know how they got there and the crossroads they faced to plunge them into their own personal abyss.
Not as out-and-out funny as Tomcat In Love or as cumulatively powerful as, say, The Things They Carried, I would still rate July, July within O'Brien's top four.
If you like to read a top author with good ideas, fully fleshing out his theme and using language beautifully, this book's well worth your time. If you prefer more action packed thrills building to a dramatic climax...this book will leave you up in the air.