Josie Long's style of comedy is pretty unique and I think it's probably for this reason that people seem to either love her or hate her. She seems to profoundly irritate people who can't stand enthusiasm and quirkiness. Yet in a world where most comedians think they have to try their hardest to be angry and offend people to stand out, Josie Long stands out by doing nothing of the sort. While she's often dangerously close to 'I'm a bit mental me!' student humour, she does manage to have enough originality to avoid getting stuck in sixth-form cliché. It is genuinely refreshing to see a comedian like this, especially in Britan where (as demonstrated by the people who react so badly to Josie) people on the whole seem terrified of admitting to actually liking things and being happy, lest they reveal something personal about themselves. It's much easier and cooler to go an about how much you hate stuff and for that reason Josie Long is probably one of the most 'alternative' comedians at the moment.
Having said that, while this show is perfectly enjoyable and made me smile, I rarely found myself laughing particularly hard. While it is a lot easier and safe to ridicule stuff, it is also basically funnier than saying how great things are. Even in Josie's set, the funniest bits are often when she is making fun of something or explaining why something annoys her. I guess humour generally comes from conflict or irrationality, both of which are rarely there when you're being positive. There's also the fact that I get the impression that the main part of the experience of Josie's set is actually being there in the room with her and an audience. Perhaps in a live setting the general good natured ambience is more apparent. I'm sure Josie herself would say that DVD is not really the best medium for viewing stand-up, the best way to experience it is in person.
The extras on this DVD are very good though - there's a whole extra show (Kindness And Exuberance, filmed the year before Trying Is Good) which is bootleg-quality but entirely watchable. I think I even preferred much of the material on that show to the main feature in fact - the bit about why she doesn't believe in being cynical is very good and sums up her view on life quite well. There's also a commentary on the main feature which is worth listening to, and if you stick the disc in your computer there's all sorts of show programs, postcards, and so on.