John Stuart Mill: Victorian Firebrand [Paperback]

 

 

Create your own review

I'd typically use a biography as a sleep aid but this Christmas present is an intellectual, philosophical and emotional caffeine-fuelled "get up and go".

It's one thing to realise that Mill encapsulates many of the ideas that represent the modern political battleground, quite another to discover that he is an inspiration and guide for a modern "life well lived". That's not to say that Reeves' compelling portrait presents an adoring fan's view of Mill. Indeed one of the elements which makes Reeves' account so engaging is that he sees Mill warts and all and is quick to acknowledge the occasional gaps between thought and action. The life story and the political thinking are thus seen in tandem. This is not a dry analysis.

Mill represents one of Britain's few genuine claims to a philosopher and intellectual of world import and Reeves reinforces and does justice to that status. This is a work which genuinely sheds light on what it means to be liberal.

Not simply for those who are already politically engaged, this is essential reading for anyone who believes society does exist and they are part of it.

Although he was a Liberal, don't get confused by his `open-mindedness' when leading Victorian Liberal William Gladstone labelled the great John Stuart Mill. I suspect all students will have tremendous affection for Mill even though they may not care for liberals.

In this short review, I will concentrate on the value of the book for the jurisprudence undergraduate because Richard Reeves has produced the first proper and worthwhile study of Mill for 50 years which will be of great benefit to scholars aiming for a `First'. The first thing to do is look at the index at the back because the fifteen chapters, plus the prologue and epilogue, give you the essence of the man as a human being whilst some careful cross-referencing with the likes of Bentham and Co. will give you your legal learning and quotes.

Look specifically at chapters 11(`On Liberty') and 12 (`To Hell I Will Go') because Reeves offers some useful twenty-first century quotable insights into our "Victorian Firebrand" and some of his overt political failings such as his opposition to the introduction of the secret ballot! Frankly, I have never thought of Mill as a firebrand as the world he left us with was unquestionably better for his efforts as Reeves acknowledges... and, as he concludes, it still is.

This masterly work gives Mill his proper place in jurisprudence and the wider field for his utilitarianism, described by Reeves as "a word with a divided personality, meaning one thing in common use and the opposite in formal philosophy". What I found particularly inspiring with this biography is the political and historic context in which Mill has been placed because, to understand the value of philosophy and the importance of jurisprudence either as a tutor or learner, is clearly to understand also the historical period in which the thoughts first prevailed, and I am not talking Plato here.

Reeves manages to succeed with his task magnificently throughout the 487 pages and the massive details contained in the notes afterwards. Of particular delight, as a break from the prose, are the splendid series of illustrations and the photographs which firmly place this book at the forefront of both legal and political biography. It is a work which I felt at home with from the outset, written in readable English with the detail needed (and without the footnotes). I am sure that great American, Benjamin Franklin, whom Mill so clearly admired, would agree entirely.

As some commentators have acknowledged, this work is long overdue but it does give us the complexities and contradictions of the man together with his ideals which many of us would like to have if we had our feet firmly taken out of the cemented ground. Will Hutton feels the book comes at a timely moment `when both socialism and liberalism have lost their way'! Hmm! I would not really equate today's Liberal Democrats or New Labour (if it still is under Gordon Brown) in any way, shape or form with John Stuart Mill- Mill was a man of his time just as my forebears were liberals and radicals, whilst I am a radical Tory in the modern David Cameron tradition as contemporary politics continues to be turned on its head ideologically.

I will end where Reeves begins...which is a defining moment for Mill in the 1823 St James's Park walk and discovery of the newly killed baby which led to the sort of behaviour which singles Mill out as the highest-ranking philosopher of his century and someone we need a great many more of today: being a human being, an activist and a thinker.

This authoritative work illustrates that the problems faced by Mill in the nineteenth century have such similar relations today when one reads of his passion for reforms of alcohol, gambling, prostitution (and their lordships), and whose life was spent in the pursuit of truth and liberty, and the promotion of happiness for all. It is a remarkable story and Richard Reeves gives us a new insight into this radical reformer who's shaping of Victorian England has so many messages left still unread now: it is a great read as well as being a great book about a great man - I am a fan, and you will be, too, when you read the book.

To those of us who are not historians but are nonetheless interested in the subject, this is an outstanding and highly readable biography of a truly great philosopher, politician and economist. Importantly, it also provides an excellent account of the era in which he lived and those whose philosophy or politics he disagreed with. Mill is, like everyone, a flawed individual and some of his writings make little sense looking at them from a 21 century perspective. However, the bulk of his work is highly relevant today and Reeves biography provides a powerful insight into Mills thinking and his background. THis is a must read book for anyone who wants to understand the philosophical underpinnings for the liberal society in which we live or aspire to.

Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review

› See all 6 customer reviews on Amazon.co.uk

 

5.0 out of 5 stars An intellectual bodice ripper!
This is a fascinating and compelling read which reflects considerable study and research by the author, Richard Reeves. Read more

Published 7 days ago by Junglies

4.0 out of 5 stars Well Worth Buying
Richard Reeves has written a fine biography. He covers everything one could reasonably expect. His judgements on Mill are usually sound, as well, though sometimes he was off the... Read more

Published on 24 Jan 2009 by J. Goddard

5.0 out of 5 stars Fine biography of Mill
Richard Reeves, the newly appointed director of the think-tank Demos, has written a fine biography of John Stuart Mill, `the foremost public intellectual in British history'... Read more

Published on 1 Dec 2008 by William Podmore

Search Customer Reviews
Only search this product's reviews

› See all 6 customer reviews on Amazon.co.uk

Search Listmania!