This magnificently produced and superbly illustrated volume represents a lifetime of study by Mary Webster of the life and works of the much-travelled Zoffany, a truly fascinating Anglo-German artist (for such we should consider him, as the first thirty-odd years of his life in Germany, where he was born, and Italy where he studied, was negligible compared with the 50 years he spent in the service of the British royal family, aristocracy and wealthy, whether in London, Italy or India). Mary Webster was author of the still valuable 1976 NPG exhibition catalogue, but as she remarked in that catalogue, the large book published in 1920 by Lady Victoria Manners and G.C. Williamson, the previous 'standard' text, is a 'dangerous' book, being full of inaccuracies and stories which she entirely disregarded in the 1976 catalogue, but which which she carefully but silently reassesses here in the light of a great deal of very valuable evidence that she has painstakingly gathered and after many years of thought; this is praiseworthy indeed. The problem with this book, wonderful though it is, is that, after fifty years of study, despite having produced a highly readable book, it does not contain, as one would expect, a catalogue raisonné of Zoffany's works. The appendices are valuable, the list of sale catalogues and list of prints here are of course useful, but they are no substitute for the catalogue raisonné of all Zoffany's works which scholars and collectors must have hoped would be included. Maybe Webster will yet produce this as a supplement to the present volume, as it is badly needed? And maybe she is waiting to see what the scholarly fallout will be from the Zoffany exhibition due to open at the Royal Academy shortly, before issuing this? But if this does not happen, dealers and scholars and interested members of the public will have no recourse but to the catalogue of works published in 1920 by Manners and Williamson (and now available in the online open library in pdf form) which Webster's scholarship was expected to supersede entirely and which she otherwise rightly condemned in 1976 as 'dangerous.' If there is one other regret this reader has in her Zoffany scholarship, it is that Webster has now dismissed, alas justifiably, one 'dangerous' story which he loved: that Zoffany was shipwrecked off the Andaman Islands on his journey home from India and lots were drawn by the starving survivors as to which sailor they should eat - the idea that Zoffany was ever the first and last member of the RA to have been a cannibal was, always, to put it mildly, quite delicious!