Job: a Comedy of Justice [Mass Market Paperback]

 

 

Create your own review

Many people seem to prefer (or despise) Heinlein's more "political novels" such as "Starship Troopers" and "The Moon is a harsh Mistress". My favourite Heinlein book has got to be "Job". It's an SF-story about parallell universes. It's a story about a modern Job who is tested by his God. It's a love story featuring two people from (in more ways than one) different worlds. Starting out as pure comedy, the book progresses to raise some interesting questions about religion and our relationships to it. Not a major philosophical work, but a highly entertaining and thought-provoking read, loaded with humorous remarks and insightful observations. Heinlein's funniest book (and I have read them all). In the end, however, it is really just a wonderful love story.

Whenever the subject of Heinlein comes up, certain works of his always seemed to get mentioned, such as his Starship Troopers and Stranger in a Strange Land. But for some reason, there is very little comment about this book, which may arguably be the best of his late period "World as Myth" books.

The plot is comparatively simple: Alex Hergensheimer, fundamentalist priest, finds himself shunted from alternate reality to alternate reality, with his only constant his new-found love-at-first-sight Margrethe as his traveling companion and the clothes on his back. Such changes impose severe hardships, as again and again he finds himself without spendable money or records of who he is, and must survive by taking any jobs he finds available, chiefly dish-washing. Culture shock is also heavily prevalent, as his own ideas of what is proper in terms of women's dress, public displays of affection, acceptable language, and what should be (in his mind) the one and only acceptable religion are continuously rubbed headlong into the facts and customs of totally different cultures. Alex is quite a bit of a prig, whose ideas on papists, Jews, and blackamoors are horrendously prejudicial, and finds these changes very difficult to take. His take on the entire experience is that either he is totally paranoid, that these shifts are directed solely at him, or that these are signs and portents of the coming Armageddon. That his paranoia is justified and Armageddon really is just around the corner is the logical conclusion to this, but what he finds and does in both Heaven and Hell may not be at all what the reader is expecting.

Alex is a fully developed character, in some ways a typical Heinlein ubermensch, as he concentrates on surviving in each new world and showing great practicality and intelligence in doing so, and at the same time violently different from just about every other character Heinlein ever created, with his closed mind and highly religious outlook.

But despite his continuous pig-headedness and "I know I'm right" attitude, there is a certain nobleness and steadfastness of character that shines through, that in the end fully justifies his selection as a modern day Job. There is a very large amount of very biting satire and humor prevalent throughout this book ("Is this Hell? Or is this Texas? Both."), and those with fundamentalist Christian beliefs may find this book extremely upsetting as Heinlein takes the exact words of the Bible and shows just what they would really be like. In fact, it has been denounced as blasphemous by Jerry Falwell's Moral Majority, a reaction Heinlein was probably trying to provoke.

The book is also quite inventive, showing off Heinlein's masterful world-building skills as he details not just one but several alternate worlds and technologies, and he even takes a crack at detailing a scientifically plausible Hell-world and the infrastructure of a Heaven with plumbing and public transportation. But the basic idea behind all the world-shifting and religious trappings is an idea that he first tackled in "The Unpleasant Profession of Jonathon Hoag" and "They", which he wrote very early in his career, an idea which runs throughout his late period books, that the world we see is an artifact, a stage setting, created by some fabulist for his own purposes. This book also clearly shows some of the literary influences on Heinlein, mainly James Branch Cabell and Mark Twain, along with highlighting the fact that Heinlein was brought up in the heart of the Bible-belt, and had an extensive knowledge of the Bible.

Some have complained that the book's ending has too much of a deus-ex-machina feel to it, but this is one case where the `God' is quite literal, and I found the ending quite fitting. But a warning: the last two chapters must be read very carefully, especially in terms of what characters are present (names are quite important), as there are a lot of hidden statements and meanings hiding behind the bare happenstances that are detailed.

I did not think this was one his great books when I first read it, but every time I give it a re-read, it impresses me more and more as quintessential Heinlein at the peak of his form, a joy to read and an illuminating volume of ideas and thoughts that require some serious contemplation.

---Reviewed by Patrick Shepherd (hyperpat)

I recently read this again after reading it first many years ago and enjoyed it just as much, even knowing what happens.

Many situations in the book are very amusing and the whole idea is irreverent but never intended in my view to insult any religion.

It is very different and is not what I'd describe as SF exactly although there are some elements there.

Heinlein's later work seems to deal with love and affection between people, decency, fairness and indeed Justice as in the title. From my point of view he deals with these subjects well and in a natural, untwisted way.

Some of thw worlds visited are very funny, especially those most like ours. One constant is that whilst the powerful and almighty appear bent on being as unhelpful as possible, there is a willingness running through the whole story of the ordinary person to offer nothing but help and decency.

It is outrageous and funny and not one to miss.

Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review

› See all 8 customer reviews on Amazon.co.uk

 

2.0 out of 5 stars A juvenile atheist comedy
I'm not a religious man, and neither was Robert Heinlein. Yet, I can't stand Heinlein's juvenile humour. Read more

Published 13 months ago by Ashtar Command

4.0 out of 5 stars Life without love is just a cosmic joke
The writings of Robert Heinlein's later years are a good bit different from the science fiction classics he produced in his prime. Read more

Published on 15 Aug 2005 by Daniel Jolley

2.0 out of 5 stars Way too much preaching.
This book has an intriguing premise. Our protagonist, Alexander Hergensheimer, a Christian fundamentalist trapped in an unhappy marriage, finds that without warning he is shifted... Read more

Published on 16 July 2005 by Preacherdoc

5.0 out of 5 stars A comical & wry look at life and love with a hidden theme
A great Heinlein book. The master story teller does it again. Not a typical technical Heinlein more of a wry look at society and how other nationalities look at life, death and... Read more

Published on 2 July 2001

5.0 out of 5 stars Superb... you MUST read this.
The story of a simple man used and abused by various deities just to prove a point. Brilliant touches when dealing with religion, sex and nudity, all in Heinleins unique style.

Published on 22 Mar 1999

Search Customer Reviews
Only search this product's reviews

› See all 8 customer reviews on Amazon.co.uk

Search Listmania!