J. S. Bach
Violin Concerto BWV 1041, 1042, 1055, 1056
Rachel Podger - violin
Brecon Baroque:
Bojan Cicic - violin
Johannes Pramsohler - violin
Jane Rogers - viola
Alison McGillivray - cello
Jan Spencer - violone
Christopher Bucknall - harpsichord
Recording date May 2010
After all, this ensemble is one-woman's ensemble of Rachel Podger. Other members are only playing according to her instruction. It's boring. It's a fresh performance, but a background music not exciting.
I mean it's missing a dialogue between the soloist and orchestra and the soloist and orchestra don't stimulate each other, that are necessary to play the ritornello and solo of Bach's Violin Concertos. I believe it's because Brecon Baroque doesn't take any shape of an orchestra.
Yes, I think, Mutter's BWV 1041 / 42 in
Bach Violin Concertos & Gubaidulina 'In Tempus Praesens' are better. Because I feel a thrill at the ritornello begins after the music paused after Mutter's solo (5' 26) of the first movement E major, because Trondheim Soloists give me a contrast between the ritornello of orchetra and the solo. Podger and Brecon Baroque lack it.