It's been a long time since I have read anything by Terry Brooks. I am a firm believer in authors knowing when to stop, when it comes to series'. Too many authors start a good series and spoil it by bringing out too many books. I thought, after First King of Shannara, that Terry Brooks had come to a suitable conclusion, and he had found a good place to stop. The Shannara books were all good, they stayed true to each other while adding something new, and he didn't drag it out until we were fed up of hearing about Druids, Ohmsfords, Elessedils, demons, magic, Tolkien-esque races and the Four Lands.
I have always been a believer that Terry Brooks was a far superior author to Tolkien but I was extremely wary when I saw the Ilse Witch for sale. I didn't want to read it, because after so many years, I did not want to see a good series spoiled by an author who did not know when to stop - as indeed, I felt had happened to the Landover series.
I am delighted to say that, once more, Terry Brooks seems to know exactly what he is doing. For those that loved the old books, the Four Lands, the families and the feuds are all familiar. The characters come alive and manage to have their own personalities to avoid making them copies of characters that had similar roles in previous books. In past books, my favourite character had always been Allanon, more because of what Terry Brooks did NOT say about him, that what was revealed about him. Now, for the first time, we are allowed into the mind and heart of a druid as he works, in a way we have not seen before, and Terry Brooks manages to make Walker completely human without destroying any of the danger, mystery, mistrust and power that makes druids so feared and ostracised by other characters. As one reviewer pointed out, encounters can be a bit weird to keep track of, but as it is the first book of a new series, I am willing to put my thoughts on that on hold until I have read the rest.
All in all, Terry Brooks has done himself proud with this book. Not only does it compliment the previous Shannara books, I actually think it improves upon them. Something I don't think many authors can claim success at when revamping old series into new ones.