As a Spaniard who has lived in Ireland for sometime I was obviously interested in this book. I think it is well written and after all not too partial. In my opinion, although the author seems to show more affection for the Irish who joined the International Brigade than for the ones who joined Franco; at least, this war is not portraited as a story of goodies (left wingers) against badies (right wingers).Anyway, there's the tendency in this book to speak about the executions carried out by the nationalist army, overlooking most of the crimes comitted by the other side.Both sides must have been brutal (according to the number of casualties)and mainly antidemocratic(fascists/comunists).We should't forget that 2 years before the war comunists had tried to bring down the democratic system in Asturias (Northern Spain), that the years before the war there were daily political killings carried out by right wingers, comunists and anarchists....
Anyway, can anyone be as incompetent as O'Duffy is described in the book?
Although my comments may look very critical I've really enjoyed the book, and found it very instructive and entertaining. As I said before I think the author has been quite impartial.