I've been a Zorn fan for several years, ever since listening to Cobra and Xu Feng. I own and love many of his recordings, especially the Naked City and Painkiller boxsets and the two Electric Masada albums. I also really enjoy the previous Moonchild releases, particularly Six Litanies for Heliogabalus and The Crucible, and bought Ipsissimus with great expectation on the first day of release.
First, this isn't a bad album. The musicianship is of course top notch. Marc Ribot's guitar work is a wonderful addition to the lineup, and Dunn's bass is if anything even more awe-inspiring than ever.
Unfortunately, the album leaves me cold and begs the question, "What's the point?" Despite the addition of Ribot, it sounds like a rehash of previous Moonchild and Zorn themes to me. The three apparitions tracks are the familiar chaotic, dissonant works reminiscent of his file card techniques and other improvisations; I will probably never listen to them again. The Book of Los was promising, as it led me to hope the album would build on the more melodic direction of The Crucible. Alas, not so.
Unlike the above mentioned Moonchild albums, Ipsissimus doesn't seem to have a unifying theme. The artwork and Book of Los track indicated a William Blake inspiration, but I don't hear it. It really just sounds like a random collection.
And I must say, with apologies from a fan: I'm getting tired of Mike Patton. In some contexts he fits perfectly (Astronome and Six Litanies, for example) but here I just find him annoying. I believe future Moonchild works would benefit from his absence.
Really, though, I think the problem is Zorn himself. He may be a genius, but even geniuses can produce mediocre work. When a genius is in the position to release whatever he or she wants, self-editing is critical. Zorn now seems to be giving us absolutely everything he does without self-critique; just look at the size of his discography.
Again, the album isn't bad. If this is your first exposure to Zorn or Moonchild it may sound new, exciting and inspiring.
Maybe I'm not hearing the magic in this release. If anyone has any thoughts or keys to understanding it please let me know.