I picked this collection up because I'm utterly in love with Kirkman's other ongoing series,
The Walking Dead. This is a very different piece of work, being a more conventional (at first) story about a teenager who develops superpowers - hardly surprising since his dad is the most powerful superhero on the planet, essentially Superman with a moustache. He soon finds himself flying round in lycra as Invincible, following in his fathers' footsteps & getting involved with other superteens. But being Kirkman, there are a couple of dark twists, with apparently more to come in later volumes.
This series is essentially a homage to classic comics, being a somewhat lightweight read in the style of silver age comics. It also features many in-jokes & references to other series, such as a character investigating the murder of some heroes being similar to
Watchmen's Rorschach. It achieves this objective very well but ironically, I felt this was also a fundamental weakness. The art & characters were just as flat & 2-D as classic comics, so even when the plot took a surprisingly bloody change of direction, I found I hardly batted an eyelid since I couldn't engage with any of the characters & didn't particularly care what happened to them. It also suffered from a flaw which many silver/golden age comics had - supposedly super-intelligent characters making astonishing errors of judgement for the sake of the plot.
But despite all this, the series has... something. A certain charismatic spark which I can't quite pin down. I'm tempted to pick up
volume 2 in the hope that Kirkman has some more shocks waiting for his readers (which seems like a pretty safe bet!). After all, a lot of comic & TV series improve as they find their feet. But I also feel that if I don't try to 'get into it', I won't have particularly missed out on much.
Either way, I was very impressed with the production quality of this volume. These hardcover reprints feature full-colour, high quality, oversized pages which bring out the best in the art & absolutely tons of extras (character sketches, cover designs, afterword by Kirkman, etc) which take up almost a quarter of the book! It's also satisfyingly thick, containing no less than the first 13 episodes of the monthly comic, which I hear are incredibly hard to get hold of these days.
All in all, if you like good old-fashioned superheroics with a modern twist, then this is for you. But personally, I feel that the best concept in the world still needs well-rounded characters, so ultimately found myself wishing that it had more to offer.