An Intimate History Of Humanity [Paperback]

 

 

Create your own review

Theodore Zeldin commences his brilliant, quirky, erudite, tour-de-force of the history of all humanity with the subject quote, made by a 51 year old French domestic servant. But why start a history, any history, by looking at admittedly one of life's very minor characters, and a self-confessed failure at that? But that is precisely one of Zeldin's principal points, and it certainly draws the reader in. Alistair Horne, another superb historian, used exactly the same technique in his equally excellent history, A Savage War of Peace: Algeria 1954-1962 (New York Review Books Classics) when he quotes British Prime Minister Harold Macmillan who referred to the Algerian town of Setif as "A Town of No Great Interest," and proceeds to prove exactly the opposite. So too with Zeldin, who after a brief vignette of the servant, Juliette's life, goes on to say: "My purpose is different. Behind Juliette's misfortunes, I see all those who have lived but thought of themselves as failures, or been treated as such. The worst sense of failure was to realize that one had not really lived at all, not been seen as an independent human being, never been listened to, never been asked for an opinion, regarded as a chattel, the property of another." Zeldin segues into a discussion of slavery, real and de facto, the fate of the vast majority of humanity, be it self-imposed or imposed by others: "And today, all those who prefer to do what they are told rather than think for themselves and shoulder the responsibility..." And to those who have ever suffered through corporate meetings, Zeldin continues his theme loud and clear: "There has been a waste of an opportunity every time a meeting has taken place and nothing has happened...In most meetings, pride or caution still forbids one to say what one feels most deeply." The theme of slavery, in its many forms weaves it throughout Zeldin's account. Consider much latter in the book, from today's headlines a section proclaiming that "people agree to be bullied if they can bully someone else," the author says: "In real life, for the last 5,000 years, the vast majority of humans have been submissive, cringing before authority and, apart from short-lived outbursts of protest, sacrificing themselves so that a small minority could live in luxury." Or again, in another section: "Thus an elite accumulated power, enabling it to live in high luxury, and to stimulate the flowering of the arts, but civilization was for many little more than a protection racket."

The above is just one of the many topics in which Zeldin provokes thought about "the record book," what passes for our tales and accounts of the past, and how we relate to each other today. There is much on male-female relations, so stimulating no Viagra is needed. Consider some sample chapters: "How men and women have slowly learned to have interesting conversations," "How new forms of love have been invented," and "Why there has been more progress in cooking than in sex." In the second of those mentioned chapters, the author says: "Attraction became explosive when ignited by fun. Ibn Hazm, the most famous Arab authority on love, said, `Of love the first part is jesting and the last part right earnestness.'" Zeldin erudition allows him to draw from the world's cultures, so he can address the Chinese fetish on "how deformed feet became sexually arousing," and the culturally transcendent fetish of stilettos.

And on economics, Zeldin traces some of the problems that are bedeviling us today to the 18th Century doctor of nervous diseases, Bernard Mandeville, who wrote The Fable of the Bees and Other Writings: Or Private Vices, Publick Benefits Zeldin says: "The consumer society lost its sense of direction when it adopted two myths to guide it. The first was that private vices are the source of public prosperity. Avarice, pride, envy, and greed, rather than friendliness and kindness, are the necessary bases of a successful economy..." Zeldin has another section on astrology, and the enduring power of totally irrational beliefs on our behavior.

Zeldin is British, and has dedicate much of his life to writing about the French, so it is only natural that his historical examples are skewed toward the French experience. Being an intellectual there, he comments: "Personal vendettas and power struggles have, of course, been endemic in France's intellectual life..." He quotes Antoinette Fouque, who wrote for the publishing house "Seuil,": `Why did Beauvoir not join the Resistance, instead of cycling around the country, having affairs?' Figure that is a double pay-back. But then in a twinkle, he is in Japan, discussing The Tale of Genji (Penguin Classics), written between AD 1002 and 1022, and says: "Those who say Japan can only imitate will be astounded by this extraordinarily readable and intelligent precursor of Proust, Murasaki Shikibu."

If you've read only one history book, and are looking for the second, I'd highly recommend this one, which is our past from a refreshingly different, thought-provoking perspective, and is rich in endless nuggets of "the history you do not know." I must add Zeldin to my small, but growing list of 6-star books.

(Note: Review first published at Amazon, USA, on October 11, 2010)

I endorse Cassini24's review and would add the following comments.

Zeldin tends towards sweeping statements. When he touches on subjects I know about he is sometimes (a) not quite right (b) misleading or (c) wrong. This makes me wonder whether the same applies to matters upon which I cannot make a judgment of my own. It makes me reluctant to take him on trust.

The case studies that begin each chapter often have little discernable relationship to the analysis that follows. The people appear selected to meet Zeldin's agenda. They tend to be high or low achievers (personally, work-wise or artistically) whereas a representative sample would surely have produced more middle ground.

But ultimately you don't have to agree with such conclusions as Zeldin reaches and I suspect that is not the point. There are interesting insights and from previous reviews some readers have obviously taken a lot from the book. Any book that produces food for thought can't be all bad. But I find it difficult to see how this can be a five star read.

This is a book for anyone who wants to escape above the drudgery, dream a little and open your eyes. Very interesting and thought-provoking, and full of humanity. I took away a lot from this book.

Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review

› See all 11 customer reviews on Amazon.co.uk

 

2.0 out of 5 stars An intimate history of Theodore Zeldin's ramblings
I picked this book up as it looked really interesting, and was well reviewed on its cover. It presents itself as a series of philosophical musings on human relationships... Read more

Published 8 months ago by anozama

4.0 out of 5 stars a French mousse dessert with nuggets of high culture
I'll be brief about this rather remarkable and sweet book. What really grabs you are the chapter headings. Read more

Published on 10 Sep 2009 by H. Julian

5.0 out of 5 stars This book opens up possibilities for understanding ourselves
We think our innermost thoughts in cultural contexts and Zeldin's examples can send us of on new journeys of exploration. What might I be like? Read more

Published on 2 Sep 2007 by Judy Barber

3.0 out of 5 stars mildly diverting but ultimately shallow
A mildly diverting and interesting analysis of human relationships over the centuries and across cultures, illuminated by case studies, mostly of French women. Read more

Published on 2 Sep 2004 by CASSINI24

5.0 out of 5 stars Brilliant and unique!
I took the book off the shelf in the book shop, opened it somewhere in the middle to read a few sentences and was hooked. Read more

Published on 15 Jun 2004 by M. Torma

5.0 out of 5 stars History on steroids
This is one of the most unusual and interesting books I've ever read. It's not easy going - at least at first - but it certainly rewards patience. Read more

Published on 27 April 2002

5.0 out of 5 stars My favourite non-fiction book of all time
This is my favourite non-fiction book of all time. It is very accessible and was a joy to read. It is truly unique; like no other book I know of. Read more

Published on 8 Jun 2001

5.0 out of 5 stars A book that can clear the fog in many minds.
This is a brilliant piece of writing that inspite of drawing from so many sources does not loose its focus nor does it get burdened by any academic jargons. Read more

Published on 30 Oct 1999

Search Customer Reviews
Only search this product's reviews

› See all 11 customer reviews on Amazon.co.uk

Search Listmania!