John Freely certainly loves his subject: his description of Istanbul and its glorious architecture is sensitive and touching. However, his book ultimately fails in its objective: it is neither an in-depth history of the Seraglio, the Harem where the Sultan's wives lived, nor is it a good description of the "private lives of the sultans", as the subtitle of the book promises.
Throughout, the author seems undecided on whether he should follow themes, or just pursue a chronological narrative. The result is a mixture of both, and this remains unsatisfactory. John Freely's habit of applying the same format to the description of every sultan - how many years he spent in the "Cage", hidden away while he awaited his turn at succcession to the throne, how many children he fathered and where he is burried - makes absolutely no sense and is utterly tedious.
Those interested in a bit of "thrill" about sexual dalliances will get nothing from this book. And those interested in a serious, "personal" history of the Osmanli dynasty which ruled the Turkish empire will not be satisfied either.