Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
10 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
MORE ADVANCED ART OF MURDER, 25 Dec 2008
The last theoretical manifesto of thriller-writing I read was Chandler's `The Simple Art of Murder'. Chandler was blowing his own trumpet and uttering a blast of it against the monstrous regiment of women (Agatha Christie, Dorothy Sayers etc) who dominated the genre in his time. What he produced became a famous piece of literary criticism, maybe indeed a piece of literature in its own right. What Chris Wood is doing is both less and more ambitious. This book has no pretentions to being literature, but the thriller genre has come on a lot since the day of Philip Marlowe, and Chris Wood offers would-be authors a handy manual of tips on what to try to achieve and particularly what to avoid.
He casts his net quite widely, including James Bond stories, the Godfather series, Graham Greene's Brighton Rock and other productions outside the `whodunit' category that Chandler restricted himself to. I suppose this is only realistic - it would not make much sense these days to try to exclude so much of what has become the mainstream. If the consequence of that is that a good deal of the advice offered could apply generally to novels that are nobody's idea of `thrillers', then that is a consequence we just have to accept. Chris Wood proceeds mainly by examples, and without actually having counted the examples I'd guess that more than half of them are taken from films. Even assuming that his advice is aimed at authors and not film producers or directors I still have no real problem with that until he raises the matter of background music, which surely should have been restricted to a footnote at the most. On the other hand, if films can feature so prominently, why is there not more about detective series on television? Some of these, e.g. Morse or Inspector Frost or my own beloved Taggart series, are genuine pukka `mysteries' as we used to say, and those should at least form the basis of any treatise on `thrillers'.
The points made seem sound and sensible for the most part to me. I am not about to write any thrillers myself, but I have read plenty of them in my time, and I could certainly consider adding to my experience any thriller written to the Chris Wood quality assurance standard. We should probably be grateful that he has put the effort into pulling the threads together even to the extent that he has. Chandler followed his own advice and produced out-and-out masterpieces. Perhaps Chris Wood will do the same. Meantime by way of practical assistance I can offer him a few corrections he might like to make when the book is reprinted. Surely it is Hannibal Lecter, not `Lector' as he has it throughout? On p 47 I also think he probably means Nigel Stock. Starting from p 29 when I started to notice there are the following errata -- p 29 `in's'; p31 `inciteful'; p 33 `mains'; p 64 `who's'; p 65 `gargantuum'; p 71 `mislead'; p 90 `reigns'; p 131 `Potempkin'; p 142 `breath'; p 159 `plaigarism'. Among the many helpful don'ts, don't neglect accuracy.
|
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Useful and well produced, 15 April 2009
I love reading books about writing as it's the next best thing to writing itself. This is a well produced book with a larger than average typeface which won brownie points from me as I like reading when I'm on the bus or train.
It is arranged into useful sections covering characters, plot, atmosphere and dialogue amongst others, by reference to films and books in the genre. There are useful lists of films to watch and books to read even if you do not wish to write thrillers.
The section I found most interesting was the one about the anti hero, who I had never really considered before. The information about atmosphere has made me look at books and films with a more analytical eye so that I can improve my own writing with the addition of the small details which make all the difference.
This book is an excellent concise guide to how thrillers work from an enthusiast and I shall read and watch them with more understanding having read it. I would recommmend it to anyone not just writers.
|
|
|
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Informative. Enjoyable. Easy to read. But who's it for...?, 19 Feb 2009
Despite having a subtitle long enough to strangle a cat, this is a really accessible and entertaining wee book. I'm not certain who would be likely to pick it up, because much of the ground it covers is basic stuff which I expect most fans of the genre to be very familiar with. Why would you consider writing a thriller if you weren't already a fan, I ponder?
However, the details in each chapter which refer constantly to examples from films, books and TV, are thoroughly engaging. This book is more like a conversation in a pub than a lecture from an expert; I found myself arguing a point or two with the author (I'm not sure that Mr Blonde really is any kind of hero, you know; surely he's just too mental for that? Etc) over some bones of contention, while making notes to catch up on some older films which I've obviously missed.
In fact that's one of this book's strongest points. Even if you're not remotely considering writing any sort of thriller, it gives you a great reading/viewing wishlist of the author's most influential and admired thrillers. Much of the content relates to recent offerings, and the author obviously adores No Country For Old Men and other works from the Coen brothers, plus Se7en and Reservoir Dogs, but the classics get a tip of the hat at appropriate moments too.
When I started reading 'The Ingredients...' I was pretty sure that it wasn't a book I'd get very much from. By the time I'd finished it, I was sad it was over. The writing is accessible, punchy and to the point. The publishing is no-frills (like that matters...?), and the subject matter is of continual interest to me. Why are we attracted to the evil in life, and why do we fictionalise it so much? Read this, and get a little closer to understanding.
8/10
ps; if you really do want to write crime fiction then Lawrence Block's Telling Lies for Fun and Profit 'Telling Lies for Fun and Profit' covers the subject in greater depth and with the experience gained from that authors extensive career
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|