I couldn't help but look at some of the reviews, admittedly rather a long time after the 2nd edition now. The book is really designed as a primer on the subject, and also to maintain the links between what is going on in the equity market, and what is going on internally inside the corporates. As such we steered a path between making the book overly complicated and hence off-putting, and between making it overly simple. It was never designed to sell SAP software, as one reviewer suggested, and indeed, its overall position in the PwC offering was less clearcut than it should be. Perhaps to remind readers that it originated from the old PW company might explain rather more. The descriptions and analysis of the models are reasonably correct, including that of the CFROI model - at least judging by the materials I had to hand. The critique on the replacement value of assets and the corresponding weakness of the EVA model is a valid point, made elsewhere, but also picked up in the book I believe. Yes the book has been used extensively by PwC people, but by no means exclusively so. Yes, we did go on to develop a VBM offering out of it, but again not exclusively around the book - though it helped. The combination of the approach (Valuebuilder, which is not for sale), capital markets, consultancy and corporate governance issues remains very useful, and rather distinct from a number of other offerings in the market. So, do continue to buy it and read it !!