Jars of Clay like several other bands were unfortunate in that they achieved such musical excellence with their first effort that they are never going to live upto that with latter albums and this is sadly the case with If I Left The Zoo.
I say sadly but I don't wish to give the impression that this is a bad album, merely that Jars Of Clay was outstanding.
As for this, it is a marked improvement on their second effort, Much Afraid, and is closer to the original both in terms of their sound. I enjoyed pretty much the whole thing, with a standout track for me being Sad Clown. Again, they are lyrically worth listening to, and the music is solid enough.
I would be happy to recommend this to both Christian and secular music fans. Jars continue to be one of the only Christian bands capable of making music that can hold it's own with the majority of mainstream music.