Most Helpful Customer Reviews
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Very Inspiring and easy to read! Gets you thinking!, 14 Dec 2009
This review is from: I, Cyborg (Hardcover)
My Review:
A very inspiring book indeed! I was a bit cautious to buy this after reading some of the reviews given by other amazon users however it turned out to be brilliant. The author does a good job of describing the technology to the average reader without the need for them to have knowledge in academic subjects. It also reads like a story which again is very important for the average reader.
This book reads a bit like a biography discussing the inspirations and progress that lead to the experimetns discussed. What is actually being done in the experiment is discussed along with concerns and what they could achieve in future. I would recommend this if you are interested in the progress made towards the field of Cybernetics BY Warwick. (I'd like to point this out as a previous reviewer claimed that he had hoped it would give an idea of 'what the current state of play is within the field of robotics.') However, the book also contains brief descriptions of other experiments that you could consider similar in order to express how unique the experiments described were.
Response to Negative Reviews:
I disagree strongly with the reviews given by the other reviewers who spoke of this book so negatively. Mainly because I did'nt find any evidence in the book to back up most of these claims and also because it seems that people have forgotten the years of these experiments being carried out. Particularly I would like to point out the question raised of 'What is so wonderful about transmitting muscle signals across the internet' by the reviewer 'alphix.' Which with no dis-respect to him of course, is a rather silly question given that the experiment took place I believe in either 1996 or 1997. I'd like to point out that google was founded in 1998 (To give an idea on the state of the internet during that time) and that now in 2009 the first device to interact with the nervous system has be developed, this gives an idea of how ground breaking these experiments were.
Also the criticisms about the technology not being described is rather weak also. For starters the book is clearly not suppose to be a detailed description on the devices as it is to be readable to the average reader, it can't therefore really be criticized unless it led you to believe that this what it was in fact about. To understand the technology you would need to have a knowledge of mathematics, materials, biology and electronics at least so in essence the author does a good job of portraying the technology to the average reader.
Give the book a read for yourself and decided for yourself!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
An interesting read - but not much science, 21 July 2008
This review is from: I, Cyborg (Hardcover)
Basically I agree with Matthew N Palmers review. I agree that the author doesn't paint a particularly good picture of himself. I also found the scientific info presented was fairly lacking, so I didn't have a clear picture of what was actually going on in some of the experiments. However, whilst I was a bit disappointed with the lack of depth on the science side of things, the book was interesting as an autobiographical text and also as a reminder that "cybernetic"/AI/robotic technologies (not just specifically implant - which in itself isn't a new technology) are "on their way" from science fiction, well into the here and now.
A specific point I'd make is: The author says in the book how frustrated he got with people saying he hadn't really achieved anything. Yet in 300 pages, I personally felt he hadn't countered this argument very well. Implant technology exists and ops take place routinely, radio transmission technology exists, internets and data acquisition by computer are old technologies. The author bolted them together and tested to see if they worked. Of course they worked. Why wouldn't they? It seems to me (perhaps I'm mistaken) that the only novel technology here is the nerve interface (in human) and then the novel data was that info recorded via the interface.
A lot of the other stuff detracted or confused what was being achieved. There was a lot of old science incorporated into this book..... Once the transducer has got the signal from the neuron, then it's just the same as any electrical signal. You don't need to perform an experiment to see if the transducer can control a light, a wheelchair etc. because you know the answer to this already. This stuff was more about demonstration than experimentation. I'm not saying that these demonstrations weren't valuable, I just think that they actually clouded the more experimental science done which was : The capture (and interpretation) of nerve signal information by means of a direct electrical interface into a nerve.
As I said, whilst the author doesn't come across as the sort of person you'd want to be down the pub with, I did enjoy reading his about his drive and his frustrations achieving his goal so as an interesting biog rather than an informing science book, I'd give it 3 stars.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
23 of 33 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Self Serving., 29 Dec 2002
This review is from: I, Cyborg (Hardcover)
This book says very little of any consequence about the technology or the social dimensions of this intriguing subject (human - machine direct interfacing), but rather spends most of the time on how Mr. Warwick managed the media and publicity machine that accompanied his recent cyborg experiments. His comments on being continuously spied upon by a Big Brother system are naive beyond belief (It's OK, because we'd use it for nice things rather than nasty things) - no serious discussion of how these technologies impact on privacy, or of other technologies with which they could be combined to ensure anonymity and privacy, such as cryptosystems, zero knowledge proofs, etc. etc. The technology itself is barely described, and no framework is developed for thinking about the cyborgisation (if that's the correct word to use) of humanity, either as it stands right now or how it may develop into the future. An ultimately unsatisfying, self serving, and disappointing book from someone who is living at the frontier of this technology. A missed opportunity.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|