6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Tremendous Piece of Work, and Fascinating, 21 Jun 2003
By A Customer
This review is from: The Hungry Gene (Hardcover)
This book is a truly superb work of science journalism, scrupulous reporting, excellent analysis, written in crisp,evocative prose. It tells a complex story of diverse research threads with sometimes contradictory conclusions, and it tells it incredibly well. By the time you finish this book, you will have a much better idea how to realistically interpret for yourself the claims for the latest diet or latest exercise machine or weight loss pill or program. You will have a much better idea what is "in your genes" and what is not, what you can attribute to "slow metabolism" and what you can't. In bringing together all of this diverse research and telling its story so well, this book is a landmark in explaining what sorts of things we can control, and where we are spinning our wheels.
Not only is the story of obesity research interesting and relevant to all of us, but it is extremely difficult to get the whole picture. Each article and each news story tends to cover what is novel or most fascinating about research, and the solution the author is promoting, and usually ignores the background and the consensus already formed. The Hungry Gene covers all of the central lines of research: the modification of behavior, the influence of genes, the way the body regulates its own weight, the role of food industries and marketing, and makes each set of findings clear. Equally important, the author makes it clear what we still don't know about human weight control.
There simply isn't any non-technical source to find out what is known about obesity, and the technical sources don't tell the story nearly so well, and they tend to be speciallized to a particular field. The Hungry Gene brings it all together coherently.
An important and highly relevant education-in-a-book on a deeply interesting topic. Hard to beat a bargain like that. It's rare to find a book that meets such a pressing need for scientific information in such a skillful way.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Really illuminating, 15 Sep 2011
This review is from: The Hungry Gene (Hardcover)
This is really quite a rare book. I was looking for a popular science-cum-current affairs book about obesity and dieting and, although this is nearly ten years' old and from the wrong side of the Atlantic, it was just about the only book that ticks those boxes! Is this because science knows - not suspects; knows - so little about our metabolism and its role in weight gain? This book is really excellent. There are certain nuggets of information that are priceless... and unique, actually. Such as eating X calories of sugar is better than X calories of fat because it takes more energy for the body to convert that sugar to stored fat in the body. I have never heard that before yet it is USEFUL. Shell does fall down a bit, though, because she comes across as being star-struck by the scientists in this book. It is a bit like a cult of personality rather than worshipping the science that these personalities do. It goes without saying that this book is very American too, though the science still applies. If anyone can suggest a similar book I would be much obliged.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No