Hunchback of Notre Dame [DVD] [Region 1] [US Import] [NTSC]

 

 

Create your own review

Strangely, there has never been a bad film of Victor Hugo's classic tale, and while this is indeed less successful than Laughton, Chaney or Disney's versions, this French effort is still a surprisingly good and much under-rated film. To get the most out of it, you have to bear in mind that Hugo did not write a horror story but a tale of unrequited love and anguish. There is little of the Gothic on show here; rather, everyone is trapped by a desire for what they are denied. This is much more 'Notre Dame de Paris' (the novel's actual title) than 'The Hunchback of Notre Dame': Quasimodo probably gets less screen time here than in any of the other films, only dominating the drama in the last third. Instead, as with Hugo, it uses the cathedral of Notre Dame as the thread that binds all social stratas - Kings and beggars, thieves and soldiers, gypsies and alchemists, playwrights and aristocrats - giving a vivid portrait of a time and place half imagined, half real.

Quinn is more of a brute than we're used to seeing in our Quasimodos: unlike Laughton, he's no poetic soul trapped in a broken body but an animal who is given an inkling of what it means to be human. Lollabrigida fares better than usual as Esmerelda, and if their relationship is never moving, the ending, for once taken directly from the novel, is genuinely touching.

There are problems: the dubbing is at times irritating (and there is no French-language option on the disc), while Jean Danet is quite the most embarrassing Phoebus imaginable, stilted, impossibly smug and just plain odd-looking. Some key scenes are poorly staged, most notably Quasimodo's rescue of Esmerelda, while the hunchback is not given a strong entrance. But, if you're willing to take a chance and watch it with an open mind, the pleasant surprises outweigh them. While not the most lavish version, the scale and colour of the film, particularly in scenes such as the Court of Miracles, gives us a sense of a world around these characters, the addition of CinemaScope and some impressive sets helping to broaden the scale. Delannoy's direction is occasionally imaginative, with a good eye for the Scope frame. The script (co-written by 'Les Enfants du Paradis' Jacques Prevert) is often witty and doesn't shy from the darker tragic tone of the novel. Georges Auric's score, though ill-served by the original sound recording, is also a fine effort.

The transfer on the Region 1 NTSC DVD is good, with only a few edge enhancement problems, although it seems very slightly cropped in some shots, and the failings of the early CinemaScope lenses do result in an occasional loss of detail in some shots. The DVD even includes one brief torture sequence that has long been cut from many prints, as well as the original theatrical trailer.

Kept out of distribution for years (Disney bought the rights around the time they were working on their version and shelved it), the film has not been able to gain much of a reputation. Indeed, it continues to get short shrift from many critics - 'Time Out's film guide is particularly hostile. But, as they say in Britain, 'Time Out hated it, so it must be good.' And it is - not great, but certainly pretty good.

This CD is the french equivelent of the english soundtrack release. It holds more than it's english counterpart including some of the lesser known but just as impressive songs. The french version truly is spectacular and if you have an understanding of french and love the english version, you will love this more, the show lost a great deal in translation to english and although it is still a great show, to really appreciate the beauty of it, you need to hear the original french lyrics.

In my husbands opinion this is the best version of this well known story. Anthony Quinn is superb in the lead role. I have to agree.

Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review

› See all 8 customer reviews on Amazon.co.uk

 

1.0 out of 5 stars the item is not for uk
i wish they would say cant play in uk or not suitable for uk use, unfortunaly they dont say that and you get stuck with a usless item.

Published 6 months ago by Mr. Orod Ohanians

5.0 out of 5 stars GINA LOLLOBRIGIDA--AND THAT STUNNING HOUR-GLASS FIGURE AS--ESMERALDA.
Over the past 70 years at least four beautiful,sexy actresses have all played-ESMERALDA-in-THE HUNCHBACK OF NOTRE DAME-films. Read more

Published on 20 Aug 2009 by Mr. W. J. Wright

4.0 out of 5 stars Wrong picture...great CD!
As of September 2008 they have the wrong picture here. This is not the wonderful FIAMMINGHI instrumental version, use his surname to search for that, this is instead the... Read more

Published on 18 Sep 2008 by N. Moore

5.0 out of 5 stars Vivre
This is a wonderful soundtrack - the French original and much better soundtrack. The song Vivre is absolutely beautiful. Read more

Published on 13 July 2002

5.0 out of 5 stars Absolutely marvellous show!! But do check which version CD.
I can't make out from the Amazon site whether this is the supberb double-cd and booklet with pics full French version of the show or the preview CD of some of the songs, issued... Read more

Published on 8 Jan 2000

Search Customer Reviews
Only search this product's reviews

› See all 8 customer reviews on Amazon.co.uk

Search Listmania!