Genuinely witty, "How I Paid For College" is a book I enjoyed reading a great deal. Edward, the protagonist, is charming, bitchy, and earnest - often all at once! Acito's attention to detail is also delightful - for example, when Edward mentions "My Fair Lady", he name-checks Julie Andrews rather than Audrey Hepburn (who of course made the role her own in the famous film). This is of course spot-on for a musical theatre fan like Edward, for it was Andrews who first had the role in the Broadway production. Little things like this were woven throughout the novel and as such it was more enjoyable to read.
There were a few bumps along the way. The number of bisexual students at Edward's school surprised me - as did the lack of homophobia, especially considering that the story is set in 1983. The adult characters are mostly little more than stick figures and the end is unfortunately too obvious. Moreover, the plot itself was severely lacking - there was one there, but it was very weak. More rigorous editing could have tied things together more neatly.
What it lacks in terms of plot it makes up for by sheer amusement value. While there were no real "laugh out loud" moments throughout, it was a real pleasure to read, and while I can't imagine being very inclined to reread it, I have no hesitation in recommending it, especially to fans of films such as "Ferris Bueller's Day Off". Great fun indeed.