Having been very impressed with James' previous book on the psychosocial drama that is modern parenting (They F*** You Up), I was looking forward to hearing what he had to say on childrearing, for that is how this new book sells itself. It appears to all intents and purposes to be a self-help or how-to handbook, but I found it worse than useless from a practical perspective and exceedingly frustrating to read.
On the issue of what James' has to say about being a better parent, the book falls at an important self-help hurdle by simply proposing that the reader "get help" (and expensive, legthy psychoanalytic help, at that) rather than providing any tangible help itself. In order to psychoanalyse yourself into better parenting in the manner James' recommends, you need to buy his previous book - which begs the question: what is this one for? Many of his position statements ("Daycare Is EVIL!", "If you want to go back to work, Then Go") simply place parents in an impossible and depressing Catch 22 and James' only "solution" is that we need to radically re-create our society. A point I entirely agree with - but one which does not help me deal with my toddler one iota. The book at times, seems aimed at politicians, not parents.
Stylistically and structurally, it is an irritating read. James has buried all the (very interesting) "science-y stuff" away in themed appendices (some of these quite lengthy), and you never know whether it would be best to leave them until later, or abandon the main text to read them now. He spends the first third of the book describing in detail the personality type of the "Organiser", but much of the time defines their characterstics as being opposite that of the "Hugger" - a type he doesn't properly introduce until the second act. I spent much of my time thinking that it would have been best to have introduced these personality types more completely at the beginning and interwoven their perspectives throughout the book.
Finally, comparing research on the adverse effects of daycare to research on serious sexual abuse is unecessary and unhelpful - I can imagine parents up and down the country slitting their wrists at this juncture. All in all, this was a disappointing and unecessary follow-up to his far superior They F*** You Up.