I love How I Met Your Mother, but I really felt that season 6 lost it's way a little, mainly due to the somewhat pointless introduction of Zoey, who was (thankfully) never going to be the Mother.
Season 7 (so far) is an improvement, with some great episodes I could happily watch over and over again. In this season, we are finally introduced to the Slutty Pumpkin (Katie Holmes), who proves that sometimes we can build something up in our mind to be so amazing and perfect that the reality cannot possibly compare (no pressure writers, but the reveal of the Mother had better be mind-blowing :P ). Even though the relationship between Ted and the Slutty Pumpkin goes no-where, it does allow him to let go of a fantasy- an idealised girl, who in the end, is simply not right for him. Feel free to make comparisons with Robin if you wish, depending on how you feel about her connection with Ted. I for one prefer her with Barney. They have so much more in common, and I do not feel that Robin would ever want the same things from life as Ted does. Perhaps it is just as well that she was ruled out from the very beginning, but I know some fans still seem to want them to end up together.
What I love most about this show is the way in which the writers blend together a beautiful mix of comedy and drama. Every actor on the show (main cast) is incredibly talented. Comedic timing is so important to a show like this, and each actor pulls it off so well. I love how the show can go from a somewhat ludicrous, but hilarious scene, to something moving and tragic. Season 6 achieved this with the news of the death of Marshall's father (I still can't watch that scene without shedding a tear), and season 7 does the same in episode 12. 'Symphony of Illumination' is, in my opinion, an incredible episode, and highlights what every HIMYM fan already knows- this show is not just a comedy, there is so much more to it. No spoilers, but in the episode Robin receives some news, and finds herself re-assessing everything she ever thought she wanted. It is a powerful episode, and definitely one of my favourites.
I would have given this season 5 stars based on the episodes so far, but one thing ruined it for me. In season 6, we were led to believe that Nora could be the one for Barney, yet in season 7, Nora is gone (no spoilers on why), and there is a new 'perfect' match for Barney, in the shape of Quinn (Becki Newton). Becki Newton is a wonderful actress, but the introduction of Quinn just feels like another obstacle between Barney and Robin. I know that those who are not a fan of them together will disagree, but that is just my opinion. I believed that Barney really had feelings for Nora, but suddenly he feels the same about the next girl too. I know that characters grow and mature, but part of Barney's 'charm' and what made him an interesting character was his inability to commit. Robin felt like the exception- the one girl who he thought was worth the drama, and the potential heartbreak, but now it feels like Barney could get serious with just about anyone.
The Barney issue aside, I have loved this season so far, and am looking forward to seeing how it ends. Highly recommended!