....but then who else can write like him? Let's get one thing out of the way: I'm not qualified at all to critique literature but I have do have some opinions about Naval Historical Fiction as I read O'Brian, Forester, Kent, Lambdin (and Cornwell) on a regular basis. Robert Macomber's written a pretty good book. It's not perfect by any stretch but my vote is 3.5 stars. It's a good read, and a page-turner but it's also an easy read. It seems the characters lack a bit in depth. After having finished the book today I can remember the name of the protagonist and one other character and even then only by last name. Another thing I notice is the chapters seem to be more like short stories rather than part of a novel. But that's not necessarily a bad thing as I seem to enjoy each chapter on it's own merits. Maybe that's a function of my own short attention span. One thing I will say is that I will look for Mr. Macomber's first two books and, if they are as good as this book I will read his forthcoming works. Also, as a resident of South-West Florida I enjoy his description of this area before this area turned into a mini-Miami.
I'm wavering on changing my rating from 3 to 4. The aforementioned authors seem to do a bit better job than Robert Macomber but I certainly *did* enjoy this book. For the time being let me leave my vote at 3.5 and see what happens in the future.