Not been to HK on this trip yet so can't see how good it really is. Map at back looks ok, but scale for macau says 5km, when it means 500m! Also this map is missing many street names, which are shown on the similar map within the book.
Don't know why, but I find the maps in Rough Guide easier to read than the internal ones in the LP.
For those on budget the drinking options do not seem good - there should be a key, similar to that for the eating section, so that we know how expensive a place is likely to be. All the bars seem to be of the 'trendy' type, not cheap.
I have not found info on transport from Macau airport to town.
Would always find it easier, if in the main text, along with the reference to the page the map is on, they should say the actual number of the thing (sight, pub, cafe etc) that it correlates to on the map. This would mean that we dont need to go from main text, to key, to map. Many books have this issue though.
In general the book is thorough, and has more than enough info in for the 5 day trip we are planning. I really like the walking tour suggestions. I like the fact that sights are linked geographically, but more indication to as whether the sight is a must see etc would be good. One book does a star rating by each site, which is great for just doing the main attractions.
Last time I used the Rough Guide to SE Asia and the Hong Kong section was excellent and very useful for a 5 day trip, but a bit light on eating and drinking options. Hope the ones in this book are good!