9 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
On Holiday, 26 Mar 2005
By Mr. Fourd - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Holiday [CD 2] (Audio CD)
this is the best song on the album. i like how this version fades out in the end so you can put the song on a mix without having to put boulevard of broken dreams on it too. the live tracks are pretty good, especially holiday because billie does the " the is not an anti-american song, this song is anti-war!!!!" thing. however i wouldn't buy this unless you are really into green day like me, or if you can get it cheap used, its not essential because its on the album.
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
This song is not anti american... It,s anti ... WAR!!, 21 July 2006
By Nikolai - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Holiday [CD 2] (Audio CD)
This is a good cd-single but, you should only buy it if you are a true Green Day fan or if Holiday & Boulovard are the only songs you like on American Idiot.
Track Listings
1. Holiday
2. Holiday (Live in New York)
3. Boulovard Of Broken Dreams (Live In New York)
If You realy want this CD try to find it used for less value possibly the third party sellers on amazon.com
4.0 out of 5 stars
Holiday and Boulevard of Broken Dreams are decent affairs within themselves., 20 Dec 2007
By Adrian C. "Zodiac Freak!!" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Holiday [CD 2] (Audio CD)
And I prefer Holiday for it's upbeat demeanor.
Holiday - 4.5 stars.
Boulevard of Broken Dreams - 4 stars.
Cover Art: A
Inside Art: ?
Songwriting: B+
Vocals: C+
Vocal Emotion: C
Vocal Acrobatics: F
Production: B
Length: A
4.25 stars.
Overall: B-
Goths and sexy emo boys and girls gobbled this one up for sure. They both were rather big from my point of view.