4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Good movie, Great Book, 25 Sep 2009
This review is from: A History of Violence (Paperback)
I wouldnt agree with the reviews which suggest that
A History Of Violence [DVD] [2005] was a bad film, I thought it was pretty good but it was an amazing graphic novel.
I bought it when I found it by accident in a comic shop and didnt make the connection with the film of the same name right away, while there are similarities, its only similarities. Thematically they are both about a man who has repented of a violent past, involving the mob but who cant escape the legacy. However the film departs in a big way, possibly because it is just so, so shocking from both the content and the conclusion of the book.
While the lead character having disfigured someone with barbed wire is hinted at in the film its actually portrayed in the book, there is further content which is even more shocking and sick. I would also credit this book for a number of sudden reversals which left me wondering right up to the finish how it would end and actually praying that it would have a happy ending rather than a sick tragic finish. There are not a lot of books or films or any media which can accomplish that.
While there is not the same musing about violence or ambivalence as in the film there is a kind of contrasting of the expedient and the pathological or totally sadistic and psychopathic. There is not the same ability to portray the kinds of emotional competence or self-control which the protagonist has to display in order to be able to deploy force, violence, in the way that he does or how he maintains the double life/new persona. However there are great narrative captions which give better clues to the thinking of characters and back story.
I highly recommend this book, especially to fans of books like
Road to Perdition, which is not unlike it in some respects.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
No escape from the past…, 2 Nov 2005
A History of Violence is a gripping, hard-hitting crime thriller, where two young boys misadventures with the mob lead to devastating reprisals twenty years later. A real change of tone from Judge Dredd creator John Wagner, coupled with some scratchy but appropriately grimy black and white artwork from Cannibal Corpse cover-artist Vince Locke. The format is interesting too, abandoning the usual graphic novel size for a thick paperback novel format. Maybe a touch too long, and the boys gung-ho attack on the mob doesn’t really convince, but this is still a good solid dark crime comic.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Amazing graphic novel, 14 Jan 2012
I must admit I've never seen the film, and I can see that this is a graphic novel that could be easily translated into a gore fest with little delicacy. However, the graphic novel treats what could be quite a sterotypical story with great deftness and feeling. Tom McKenna is in hiding, outwardly a pillar of his local small town, married with a little girl, the proprieter of a diner in an idyllic close knit neighbourhood. But when he shoots and kills one of a pair of predatory killers who try to rob him he becomes a media celebrity and attracts the interest of the mob. It is the characteristation, quality of drawing and careful touches which draw together the story of a man thrown back to memories of a traumatic coming of age. Very highly recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No