Most Helpful Customer Reviews
3.0 out of 5 stars
probably not what you expect, 8 Jan 2012
Anyone looking for an encyclopaedia of occultism, or alternatively a lurid catalogue of debauchery, is likely to be disappointed by this. It's a long, rambling book which, far from telling you anything specific about magic, tends to debunk the phenomenon. Levi seems at this stage to have undergone something of a re-conversion to his childhood Catholicism, which he regards as the current and final inheritor of the esoteric tradition - or 'universal orthodoxy' as he calls it. Which would be an interesting thesis, except that he doesn't really attempt to substantiate this or any of the book's other assertions. I found it a frustrating book to read. One chapter after another begins with striking insights into philosophy and spirituality - only to wander off into vagueness, symbolism and apocryphal gossip about people you've never heard of. Personally, I find A E Waite's introduction and commentary a useful framework and occasional corrective. It's hard to pin down exactly what Levi himself believes but - as Julian Cope once said - it's obviously pretty far out. And then, who is the rabbit he pulls out of the hat right at the end, as the supposed fulfilment of Christianity? Who but Napoleon? If that doesn't mark him down as irredeemably cracked, read this as at least an interesting exercise in speculation and interpretation, from a very influential figure in the modern Revival of magic.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
32 of 35 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
the Bane of Scholars is the Occultist's Reward!, 15 July 2001
By Anita Fix - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The History of Magic (Paperback)
Eliphas Levi's "History of Magic" is probably the most singularly beautiful, profoundly romantic and Personal rendering of the history of Magic ever penned. It is as much a sourcebook for the Symbolist/Decadent fin-de-siecle generation as is Baudelaire's Flowers of Evil & Paris Spleen, and ironically, Levi collaborated with Baudelaire on the work entitled:"Les Mysteres Galants".(webb. Occult Underground,266) It is essential to grasp when involved in such a historical treatise as this, that in Occultism, as in religious thought: EXPERIENCE TAKES PRECEDENCE OVER DOCTRINE. If one is seeking verifiable facts given in chronological order that is simple to digest and retain, look elsewhere. For Levi is speaking of history in relation to his own private researches, to which he had dedicated his life since entering the priesthood in the Roman Catholic Church at the age of twelve. His is also a history of magic with literary antecedents; to the likes of Aurthur Rimbaud for instance, this work of Levi/Constant's was a veritable bible, whose symbolism permeates works such as "A Season In Hell" to a deliriant degree. There is perhaps not one writer or Artist regardless of medium between the years 1860-1930 who was not at least familiar with Levi/Constant; this fact extends from his own friends, such as Balzac, de Nerval, Victor Hugo, Dumas- to Breton, Crowley, Bataille, Meyrink, Henry Miller and innumerable others! The names cover from Western to Eastern Europe, as well as North America; and it is Levi who established what we define, in its cultural sense, as "Occultism" today. It is also largely because of his pioneering Occult works that the "19th century Occult Revival" merged with the Arts of the day, giving birth to the idea of "Art as Religion, & the Artist as Priest/magician". It was in the Occult that the Artist(spelled for the 1st time with a capital)found a definition of his own position, and most granted the highest respect and admiration to the Rabelaisian personage of Alphonse Louis Constant, which is Levi's real name. Aleister Crowley's lifework was centered around Eliphas's dream of a reconciliation between the arts of science & religion, for which he laboured and set down all that was required in his Occult as well as religious and revolutionary tomes, comprising together at least 20 works. The essential question in Levi's History Of Magic is NOT the accuracy of his scholarly objectivity, but his system's origins, structure, goals, and the benefits it bestows and light shined upon the Occultist's understanding of Magic in relation to the history of magic; that Levi's historical system differs from other interpretations is due to the fact that he was not so much interested in the historical facts as much as how the history and the knowledge it produced could benefit the modern-day Occultist operating in the world today. In this respect the text is given over to interpretation of all variety of magical personages, events, accomplishments, inventions, and works. Also essential to know is that it is thanks to the genius of the Philosopher/mathmetician Hoene Wronski and his CaBalistic insights that Levi gleaned much in his Philosophical approach. One may benefit also by disregarding any facts pseudo-scholar Waite provides on Constant's background as he had at the time of writing his prefaces' not one single work in regards to the life of Levi; his critical insights however are as valid as any, and for all his seeming hostility he in reality is truly, next to Crowley, perhaps Levi's biggest fan! waite is also to be commended for providing the bibliographical sources for those seeking "established facts"( which merely means some few people agree upon what they themselves only know from yet another source of questionable reliability) It is quite evident from a philosophical standpoint that the Occultist's rewards reaped from their experience outweighs in practical value what is the scholar's bane regardless of any amount of scholarly exactitude. In this sense, as much as in the exquisitely-toned bardic prose of Levi, he has created a historical work that will outlast innumerable others, standing as it does on the merits of great literature as well as being universally regarded as a pioneering classic of Occultism.
23 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An excellent exposition of the existence of Magick!, 28 Dec 1999
By Frater AChDAE - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The History of Magic (Paperback)
This is the single greatest book on the history of the Spiritual Art and Science of Magick. My only two complaints about the book are that it's written in a rather biased view, from a purely Christian perspective (not that any other religion's perspective would be any better!) and the translator/editor, Arthur Edward Waite, once again sees fit to make some useless and innacurate remarks here and there. But still read his footnotes! He makes some legitimate points in this book!
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Only Occultism You Need, 28 Jun 2009
By V. T. Franks - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The History of Magic (Paperback)
I have read everything in the history of occultism, from the The Book of Splendors to the Picatrix, from Hermes Trimegustus to Madam Blavatsky, Agrippa to Albert Pike. This is the only book on occultism you will ever need. Levi knows more about the history of the magi than any writer anywhere. Those who believe he is inaccurate have only an outer knowledge of the inner tradition. If you have gotten to the point where you know of this book, buy it.
|
|
|