I enjoyed this book immensely. It's light, readable, insightful, and very enjoyable. A whodunnit set at a Scots-American "Highland" gathering in the southern USA it pokes fun at the pretensions of the would-be highlanders and their strange notions of Scotland and Scottishness without actually being cruel. Even the heroine and amateur investigator is not immune to these, which helps the plot along while also setting up some humorous culture clashes with a real Scot who has been dragged along for the weekend and is totally bemused by what he sees and hears.
I admit to an extra interest, being like the Scot in the story an Edinburgh man (and therefore by definition not particularly taken with tartan, bagpipes and Bonnie Prince Charlie) while my wife can, like the heroine, claim membership of Clan Chattan. (No doubt this is why a friend recommended it to me.)
My first McCrumb, but definitely not my last.