|
|
14 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Great vistas but shallow on story, 8 Dec 2004
The horse is the best thing about Hidalgo, and while his lovable antics steal the screen in every scene he's in, one can't help feeling that the movie as a whole is really just a second rate Indiana Jones. The scenery is certainly spectacular, and the film, for the most part is beautifully photographed, but the plot is so thin and, at times, the pacing is so slow that Hidalgo is only mildly entertaining in fits and spurts. The bond between man and beast is pretty much at the heart of this exotic adventure, which is reportedly based on a true story. And a blonde, charismatic Viggo Mortensen is obviously having lots of fun as Frank Hopkins, the upstart, half Indian cowboy, who in 1890, triumphs in a dangerous horse race across Arabia.The problem with Hidalgo is that the narrative is packed with such a large number of supporting Arabic characters that, at times, it's particularly hard to figure out who is who, and more importantly, who is fighting whom. Many of the subplots such as Hopkin's attempt to rescue the daughter of a wealthy sheik (Omar Sharif) from a competitor in the race, seem almost tacked on. And while the shootout between Hopkins and the bad guys is lots of fun, it's as though the director has shredded historical accuracy and inserted this gratuitous action scene just to stretch the movie's length. The story begins with Hopkins and Hidalgo wasting away their days as distance riders in Buffalo Bill's Wild West Show. Frank formerly served in the U.S. military, but after witnessing the massacre at Wounded Knee he leaves the service a broken man. An emissary of a Bedouin horse breeder sees the show and contests Mr. Hopkins' label as the world's greatest long-distance rider. A challenge is made for the Oceans of Fire race across 3,000 miles of Arabian territory. The race is brutal and many people die from the vicious heat and the massive sandstorms. The Arabian challengers resent Frank and remind him that a non-Arab has never won the race. They chide him because Hidalgo is a lowly mustang, a mixed breed, regarded as impure and extremely inferior. They also deride Hopkins' participation in the dignified race, seeing it as a violation of the event's distinction. Along the way Frank meets a spoiled, manipulative English horse breeder (Louise Lombard) who wishes that her own noble purebred Arabian stallion would win the race. She tries, at first, to bargain with Frank and then she tries to sabotage his race by trying to kill Hidalgo. But naturally, our hero, the laconic horseman cannot be bought, prevented, or turned away from his new quest. Viggo was a wise choice for this role, and his lack of dialogue doesn't detract from his economical portrayal of Hopkins because his face - with his beautifully sculptured cheekbones and dimpled chin - is just so expressive. The light and sublime beauty of the Arabian Desert is gorgeously captured, along with some striking 1890's period detail, and there are also some great looking sword-fighting sequences. Watch for the final stunning final scene - which will absolutely break your heart, of a spectacular and beautiful stampede of wild horses across the American plains. Hidalgo is a sprawling, wide-screen, western epic that is probably being a little overly ambitious. There's no doubt that the film is fantastic to look at and if you love horses, you'll love the film, but the hokey, and predictable storyline ultimately weigh the film down and prevent it from being as good as it might have been. Mike Leonard December 04.
|