These are the best walking shoes I have had (and I am comparing stuff like merrell, berghaus, trespass, salomon, scarpa, brasher). Sizing is on the generous size - i am 7.5/8 and bought an 8 which is roomy and wide fitting. I wear two pairs of socks for long walks so this is fine (for me). The leather is good quality - obviously it takes a little time to break in - treating with dubbin or wax will help. Nevertheless, I have had no problems at all with blisters or any other soreness. The sole is well attached although some of the gluing is not quite as neat as might be on a £150 pound shoe or boot. The shoe offers good support as is but personally I have added a custom insole to give just a little more support to the arch. The sole is pretty rugged but obviously these shoes are aimed at reasonably light use - serious fell walkers will want something more rugged with more support for the ankle I would think. I like these shoes a lot and am considering buying another pair just in case they are discontinued.
In summary: Price 5*, quality 4*. Really excellent overall.