Heretics of Dune (Gollancz SF S.) [Paperback]

 

 

Create your own review

Well... after the disappointing God Emperor Of Dune which seemed to drag on and on and on this came as a total shock, right out of the blue. I have only read it once but I know I will be coming back to it time and time again - this really is a classic book.

Set 1,500 years after Leto II's death, Herbert has had to start again with the storyboard and the series certainly benefits from it. New characters like the believable Miles Teg and Darwi Odrade are fantastic and the story is inspired. Certain parts are actually spine tingling in execution, and the frentic pace never lets up - the story is told from four viewpoints, namely the Bene Gesserit, the Tleiaxlu, the child Sheeana and the 'new improved' Duncan Idaho. This gives the storytelling a jolt of direction as apposed to the mundane 'God Emperor' book which plodded along to a halt.

This book is inspired in every way, and, -dare I say it-, even better than the marvellous 'Dune'. If you like Science Fiction in the slightest, you really ought to own this book. It'll hook you.

There is an incident towards the end of Heretics of Dune which neatly illustrates why this is the finest book in the Dune series since the original. Perhaps stung by the criticisms levelled at God Emperor of Dune's focus on self-important philosophising, there are several mentions in Heretics' early chapters of explosions and action, as if to promise more conventional sci-fi thrills. What we actually get are occasional bursts of violence punctuating the usual lengthy sections focused on scheming, strategising and portentous sociology. However, in the run-up to the book's conclusion, one of the main characters reaches a heightened level of physical and mental ability and embarks on an orgy of destruction, a whirling kung-fu dervish pulverising everything in its path. Lesser sci-fi books would take the opportunity to indulge in some action porn, detailing every severed limb and hand-chop. Herbert instead chooses to focus on his protagonist's heightened awareness, and the character in question reminisces on childhood experiences and considers the forces at work in the universe whilst distractedly lopping off the bad guys' heads with the occasional sweep of a hand. It's a lovely piece of sleight-at-hand - simultaneously acceding to demands for more action, whilst relegating it to an afterthought. It's an integration of crowd-pleasing and authorial integrity that Heretics of Dune consistently nails, far more so than any of Herbert's previous books at least as far back as the original Dune.

Heretics takes place several thousand years after the events of God Emperor, offering Herbert the chance to clear the decks. Prescience, a subject Herbert had all but exhausted as far back as Dune Messiah, takes a back seat here. Much of the action takes place away from the desert planet itself. The Atreides are still about, but have been absorbed into the Bene Gesserit Sisterhood, on which this book focuses. Melange remains theoretically important, but is of little practical importance to the story. Freed from the usual baggage, Herbert does something he hasn't really done in this series since Dune itself, and creates a batch of new, interesting characters, placed in a cohesive multi-strand plot that works steadily towards a definite end-game.

The final revelation of the Sisterhood's `grand design' isn't particularly convincing, but even this is put to good use by Herbert: the dependency of people on the perceived authority and vision of leaders is a key theme here, one that is gradually expanded to include the question of free will in a universe that may or may not be on a predetermined path set by God (or Leto II, in this case.) In this context, the general confusion amongst characters as to whether anyone really knows what is going on makes perfect sense.

An effort is made to develop characters properly - admittedly limited to a handful of childhood details, the occasional noting of a character's personal preferences, and the odd musing on the nature of love, but this is uncharted ground for the Dune series, where characters are usually far too busy planning the future of humanity to darn their own socks. There's a chapter where one of our grand protagonists goes for a wander through a city full of normal people doing non-epic things - a class of people conspicuously absent from the Dune series up to this point. Even sex makes an appearance (albeit epic, emotionless sex.) This newfound, tentative interest in the muck and brass of humanity ties with another key theme, one present throughout the series but brought into stark relief here - what is it to be human? Is it enough to simply self-perpetuate, or should we have a "noble purpose"? It also gives a welcome freshness to Heretics of Dune, a feel of expanded horizons and new ideas being explored.

It's not perfect - there are longueurs, particularly in the first half, and there is occasionally a sense that Herbert is recycling material. Also, it's more likely than not to be incomprehensible if you haven't plodded through Messiah, Children and God Emperor. Finally, though it is reasonably self-contained with a definite ending, it's also clearly written to lead straight into Chapter House Dune. Still, this is easily the best Dune book since the original, and is in many ways a more subtle and interesting book than `Dune.' It lacks the original's extraordinary novelty and its mythic, archetypal plot, but this is a thoughtful, intelligent and well-structured work that stands with Herbert's best.

I cannot confess to being a hardcore Dune fanatic or that I have enjoyed everone of his books, but this is probably one of the better ones. It doesn't quite have the 'epic' quality of previous ones but as a story in itself its not bad. However I felt that the despcription of Gammu (Geidi Prime) was a little dissapointing; it kept on reminding me of Canada for some reason. Also the character of Sheeana was rather underdeveloped and she was, in all fairness, a brat (although the fact that Idaho mentions this seems to imply Herbert was in on the joke). This is the first book that introduces us to the seven foot Bashar Miles Teg, one of the better characters in a Dune novel, and, of course, the Honoured Matres who are some of the best villains ever in a sci fi book. All in all Heretics seems to be set in an alternative universe to the other Dune novels, even if it is set thousands of years into the future, primarily because so much of the technology seems to have reverted, but read it as a stand alone story and its not bad I suppose...

Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review

› See all 13 customer reviews on Amazon.co.uk

 

5.0 out of 5 stars First part of an unintentional duology
Frank Herbert planned for Heretics and Chapter House (Chapterhouse in the US publication) to be part of a final Dune trilogy. Read more

Published 1 month ago by Matthew Bracher

5.0 out of 5 stars intricate, dense, enigmatic, deep
I have been slowly re-reading the Dune series of novels, all of which I read when they first appeared. Read more

Published 9 months ago by rob crawford

5.0 out of 5 stars James !!!!!
How did Brian Herbert get his name associated with this excellent book ? Probably the best of the SIX (and only six) Dune novels.

This is pissing in the temple.

Published 18 months ago by Thomas Atkins

3.0 out of 5 stars dune bugger
They scheme, they plot. They scheme, they plot.

Scheme, scheme, scheme.

Plot, plot, plot.

Then a divine miracle happens.

Published 23 months ago by H. A. Van Berg

5.0 out of 5 stars The Saga of Dune is almost over...
I began this book having read reviews of the six books in the saga that described `Heretics of Dune' as being a more action-oriented installment in the series following on from... Read more

Published 23 months ago by Fantasy Lore

4.0 out of 5 stars "Heretics of Dune"

This fifth book in the 'Dune' series finally reveals some astonishingly interesting details about the inner workings of the mysterious Bene Gesserit and the hermetic... Read more

Published 23 months ago by David Brookes

4.0 out of 5 stars `Dune' book 5
Following the interesting but rather one-track `God Emperor of Dune' this 5th book in Frank Herbert's is very much a return to the multi-layered style of the original `Dune'... Read more

Published on 22 May 2006 by Jane Aland

5.0 out of 5 stars Another incredible and weird book..
Since the time of the Tyrant (God Emperor of Dune), thousands more years have passed.. What was the Golden Path? Where was it heading? Read more

Published on 2 Mar 2004 by titus_claudius

5.0 out of 5 stars Hard at first, but I'm glad I went back to it...
Whew, the first time I read this it was a bit of a slog. The second time it was breathtaking! The last two Dune books have a kind of crystalline beauty about them, although they... Read more

Published on 4 Feb 2000 by dogsolitude_uk

5.0 out of 5 stars Frank Herbert at his best
I'm the first person to review this for Amazon. When I saw that it hadn't been reviewed yet, I couldn't resist doing so. Read more

Published on 21 Dec 1999

Search Customer Reviews
Only search this product's reviews

› See all 13 customer reviews on Amazon.co.uk

Search Listmania!