Just like a Hollywood blockbuster, this latest novel from an author I deeply like starts with a tremendous idea but does not live up to its premises. In a nutshell, here we have two universes: in the first one, magic works, the second is technology-based. They meet and they clash. It sounds interesting, and it is, but... See, all of Weber's characters in all of Weber's works are proud, noble, intelligent and selfless if commissioned officers; selfless,a bit dumb and great workers if NCOs. I normally like it (almost as much as I loved Heinlein's militaristic fiction before). You see, Asimov taught me that it's better if the enemy is not plain evil, but he's just a smart guy with a different viewpoint. This time around it all sounds a bit fishy, though. Why should two stable words with a vivid culture and strong economy start warring if the people in charge are such paragons of perfection? In this one case, one is left thinking that the reason is "we plan to write at least five books about this, so we can't have peace, that's why"...