After the shambles of 'Standing On the Shoulder of Giants' was deservedly shelved, this was the album where Oasis needed to reinvent themselves - BADLY needed to reinvent themselves. But aside from Liam's genuine effort at some decent songwriting coupled with Andy Bell & Gem Archer's input, the result remained inanely same old story, different album.
The infamous single 'The Hindu Times' is a bold, brassy intro to the album that may even have hit harder than 'Rock N Roll Star'. With a distinctly heavier guitar sound than usual, the song may not achieve greatness, but it is a befitting start. What follows is the first of several pitfalls at the hands Noel's diminishing ability to write good songs.
'Force of Nature' sounds little better than filler material & should have been demoted to a b-side at best. Along with a drumbeat that can only be described as a rip-off of Iggy Pop's 'Nightclubbing', its bemoaning lyrics led many to believe that the song was an attack on the then-newly-divorced-ex-wife Meg Matthews, an assumption vehemently denied at the time. It was hard to be anything but sceptical of thoses denials as he sings 'What you seek is a wise man's treasure / You know it's buried beneath your feet' and its stinging chorus; 'You're smoking all my stash / You're burning all my cash / I bet you knew right away / It's all over the town as the sun's gone down / On the days of your easy life'. The song doesn't even have a second verse written for it and its final line is 'Better get on your knees and pray', surly advice already offered in 'Gas Panic'. This nonsensical grumbling makes for a very tasteless song & the passage of time has done nothing to help it.
'Hung in a Bad Place' (written by Archer & somewhat reminiscent of the 'I Got the Fever' b-side) is charismatically sung by Liam along with a committed generic rock tune, albeit atypical of Oasis. The second single 'Stop Crying Your Heart Out' has potential as a heart-felt ballad, with soothing guitar riffs accompanied by a very apt string arrangement. Unfortunately, the song is let down by truly mundane lyrics. 'Fade Away' is used for the umpteenth time in an Oasis song and the 'Keep holding on' sentiment is hardly original.
Liam's first writing attribute to the record is surprisingly intuitive with 'Song bird'. Compared to his laughably bad debut with 'Little James', it's a sweet, sonic folk-rock song played with ringing acoustic guitars and an effective piano riff and it sounds unexpectedly fresh. However, at only 2 minutes in length, it disappears before it has a chance to peak.
'Little By Little' is as glum as it is perplexing. Obviously written in a somewhat philosophical mood, it seems to answer questions nobody asked. With lyrics such as 'You have to give it all/In all of your life' & bellowing 'Why am I really here?' towards the end, the song lacks sparkle. 'A Quick Peep' is an instrumental written by Andy Bell & it consists of an uninspired guitar riff underscored with a heavy bass riff. It does not venture or deviate at all and being less than 90 seconds in length, its inclusion is bordering on pointless.
'(Probably) All In The Mind' once again has a philosophical touch with lyrics that depict amateur poetry. 'And the life I'm trying to find/Is probably all in the mind'. You're on 5 albums, the lyrics do not have to rhyme!!!!! At this point, it's difficult to believe that the songs could get any more basic, but they do. 'She is Love' is obviously about a girlfriend which is a bad start; Noel has already wasted one track grumbling about one girlfriend & repeats the error by praising another one. 'All I know is that I'm in love with someone who loves me too', David Brent playing guitar in The Office anyone? Anyone?
'Born On A Different Cloud' penned by Liam, reminds the listener of the Beatles once again, a cardinal sin for Oasis at that stage. Sung in unconvincing fashion, its vibe is very similar to 'Hey Jude' or 'I Am The Walrus' (ironically). The final track 'Better Man', also written by Liam, represents what Oasis should have been doing: experimenting. Cutting guitar solos that bring an oddly punk-ish sound with distant background hum working perfectly with Liam's slurred, aggressive vocals. It's a good exit for a record that also had a good start. Shame about what was in between.
Also, for those interested, there's a hidden instrumental in the final track on CD and you have to search through about 33 minutes to find it. It's only a hashed repetitive riff similar to 'Champagne Supernova' but without the class, so it's not really worth the effort.
All in all, a disjointed fragmentary affair, cluttered with lyrical shortcomings & predictable Beatles influences. Oasis failed to exceed their own limitations with this release & pondered the question of whether they would be remembered as an album great instead of a rock n' roll great.
And sadly, the answer was Definitely Maybe.