Hearts and Minds enthralled me. The over-riding theme is the effect of immigrants, both legal and illegal, on modern-day life and how individual responses to this phenomenon define and challenge different people in different ways. The lives of six characters (five being human, the other London) are intertwined in an uncontrived manner. The five characters hail from South Africa, Zimbabwe, Ukraine, USA and England respectively. As a South African, I particularly loved the insight the writer has into subtle aspects of our country. This is unusual as in my experience only South African writers manage to capture these nuances. Even the fact that one character claims, incorrectly, that white people cannot work as teachers in schools in SA because of their colour, it is true that many white people do talk this way. (The facts are that despite affirmative action only 5% of whites are unemployed while 40% of blacks are unemployed).
The other aspect I loved about the characters is that they are so human and so real; Polly is a human rights lawyers and believes fervently in her cause; helping those who deserve asylum and trying to prevent their deportation yet she is not "goody-goody" or perfect; the reader is privy to all her insecurities and also frivolities. Job, the Zimbabwean, is a very good person but he also strays. The outsider view on the English as expressed in different ways by the characters is also very insightful and amusing. London too is a character in this novel; not glorified or prettified but shown as big, bustling, impatient, exclusionary, grimy but also pretty and village-like at times.
The storyline is compelling, I could not put it down but it is by no means one of those formulaic page-turners that I despise. The resolution of each characters' dilemma is neither predictable nor unsatisfying; a difficult balance to strike. The novel deals with human trafficking, racial and religious intolerance/ignorance, crime, institutional callousness and the single mother, all of which are highly relevant to our times. Despite being set in London, there is a universality in that many countries experience these things in different ways. I believe there are readers who, after reading this book, may well re-examine their own responses to `the other'.
The humour that popped up unexpectedly now and then had me laughing out loud. I particularly liked it when Polly, the single mother, said she needed a wife. I often said this to the men at work but had not heard it from anyone else before.
Highly recommended