THE PLOT OR PREMISE:
Hannah Trevor is a midwife in 1786 colonial America. She has 3 dead children and a dead husband, and a live daughter whose unacknowledged / unclaimed father is a neighbour. Hannah is present when the authorities discover the raped and mutilated body of another village resident, who has left behind a letter accusing some of the village elite of the crime, including Hannah's former lover.
WHAT I LIKED:
The plotting is well-done, if somewhat slow to get to the discovery of the body. So well-done in fact that this would be easily readable without the murder mystery (i.e. if it was just a historical novel about life in colonial America). And perhaps that is the highest compliment to be paid to this book -- that it works well on different levels: historical novel (the life of the midwife, the role of women), a mystery novel (who raped and killed the woman?), and, to some extent, a love story (the relationship between Hannah and Daniel, her child's father).
WHAT I DIDN'T LIKE:
I figured out the murder mystery far too early, and I spotted other murders long before they actually happened. Fortunately, the great writing carried me to the end anyways.
THE BOTTOM LINE:
A great historical mystery, 4.00 lilypads out of 5.00.
Other:
- Source: New
- Original date of review: March 2001, updated 2011
- Tags: Amateur Detective, Crime, Fiction, Historical, Mystery, Prose, Religion, Romance