OK, so I've heard Joni Mitchell, Carole King and Laura Nyro, whom Ms Sill was compared to during her brief career, and whilst none of them are without merit,in my mind her legacy tops all three of them.
Rather than an instant sensation, this album is an insidious slow-burner which, on the first two or three listens, can sound pretty but rather insubstantial. Persevere with it, however, and "Heart Food" quickly reveals itself as the richly-layered classic it is.
Perhaps the reason why both "Heart Food" and Sill's eponymous debut have aged better than a good deal of her Laurel Canyon contemporaries' output is the downbeat, fatalistic edge to the music which is occasionally present in Nyro's muse bad largely absent from both Mitchell's and King's. There's something lurking here which is just too dark for most of the 70s suburban post-collegiate crowd that their albums largely appealed to. For sure, Judee may have had the cocaine habit but the fact that she carried far more emotional baggage than most troubadours is evident from the desperate redemption-seeking lyrics of "Down Where The Valleys Are Low". Although "Heart Food album is pleasant, even celestial to the ears it's still way too intense to qualify as easy listening.
Stand-out tracks are "There's A Ragged Road", "The Pearl", "The Donor" and especially "When The Bridegroom Comes" which is just one of the most gloriously indelible pieces of soft-rock perfection to emerge from it's era, and a song that could easily have been a huge radio hit in a world where justice prevailed (or had Sill been career-oriented enought to play the game by the iindustry's rules). Highlights aside though, there isn't a single disposable moment on "Heart Food" or "Judee Sill", but if funds are tight and you can only afford one or the other "Heart Food" most likely the one to go for as it sounds fuller and more realised in many ways than it's predecessor.
Currently available affordably from Water Records, for those of you whom (like me) missed out on those expensive Rhino Handmade editions last year. However, although cheaper and easiere to find, this version does have the downside of not including any of the demos that came with the Rhino release.