Frequently Bought Together
Product details
Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
Listen to Samples and Buy MP3s
Songs from this album are available to purchase as MP3s. Click on "Buy MP3" or
view the MP3 Album.
Product Description
Review
The association of Handel's Messiah with Christmas is a comparatively recent phenomenon. Its subject is the fulfillment of Old Testament prophecy in the entirety of Christian revelation, and for more than two centuries after its first performance, the oratorio was generally considered more appropriate to Easter or Whitsun. Nevertheless, today, performances and recordings of the piece tend to proliferate in the run-up to the festive season. One might, of course, wonder whether any new version can shed further light on the work, though these two performances are often startling in their impact. Both take as their starting point the fact that Handel reworked the score no fewer than 10 times. Rather than using one of the various posthumous conflations of material, each re-creates a specific performance, as overseen by the composer himself. John Butt's version with his Dunedin Consort and Players presents the score as it was heard at its 1742 Dublin premiere. Edward Higginbottom, meanwhile, uses an edition prepared for a 1751 performance at Covent Garden that deployed singers from the Chapel Royal. In each case, familiar music is rendered subtly strange. Some of the arias in the Dublin text are radically different from the versions we usually hear. By 1751, most of the standard rewrites were in place, though the Chapel Royal choir used boys rather than women for the upper choral lines, and some of the soprano arias were re-cast for a tenor. Musicological differences aside, the two recordings are very different in mood. Broadly speaking, Higginbottom is upbeat and joyously elated, while Butt is sombre, meditative and austere. Both are immaculately played, though the Naxos set has the warmer orchestra in the Academy of Ancient Music. Butt deploys a small chorus four singers per line leading both to gains in polyphonic clarity and equal losses in grandeur. The New College sound is larger and more sumptuous. Butt's soloists seven in all, as at the premiere are less than evenly matched, though he has an authoritative bass in Matthew Brook, and a superb contralto (one of three) in Clare Wilkinson, whose heart -stopping delivery of the words "And ye shall find rest unto your souls", sets the tone for the whole performance. Higginbottom's more consistent line-up includes tenor Toby Spence, at his thrilling best, the exceptional countertenor Jestyn Davies, and three very fine treble soloists from the New College Choir. **** --The Guardian, December 2006
Product Description
Le Messie, HWV56 (oratorio en 3 parties) / Henry Jenkinson, Otta Jones, Robert Brooks, sop. - Iestyn Davies, contreténor - Toby Spence, ténor - Eamonn Dougan, basse - Choir of New College Oxford - Academy of Ancient Music, dir. Edward Higginbottom
Customer Reviews
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
49 of 50 people found the following review helpful
Format:Audio CD
I had some doubts about this Messiah before I opened it and started playing it. My doubts disappeared almost immediately and never reappeared. This is, simply put, a sensational recording of Handel's best-loved oratorio. And it has the added attraction of being the version he prepared for a 1751 London performance in which the soprano parts were taken by boy trebles. The performers here are the Choir of New College, Oxford, the Academy of Ancient Music, three solo trebles, countertenor Iestyn Davies, tenor Toby Spence and bass Eamonn Dougan all under the direction of New College's long-time music director, Edward Higginbottom.
I'm not enough of a scholar of the various performing editions of 'Messiah' to be able to cite chapter and verse about how this version might differ from others. Suffice it to say that Handel didn't actually leave a definitive version and over the many years that I've heard (or sung) performances of the work, there have often been slight differences. It did not take me long to become very fond of the three solo trebles (Henry Jenkinson, Otta Jones and Robert Brooks) in their solo outings. I was taken by every single treble solo. A friend of mine says he thinks that 'He shall feed his flock' is the loveliest thing Handel ever wrote; I don't know that I'd necessarily agree with him, but I must say that Davies and Jones do a superb job with it.
As for the choir, it is magnificent. Obviously their sound is that of the English cathedral tradition and there are some who don't much care for it; I, on the other hand, admire it wholeheartedly. Higginbottom uses fairly quick tempi and the choir handles those flying semiquavers (in, for instance, 'For unto us a Child is given') with exceedingly clean technique.... Read more ›
I'm not enough of a scholar of the various performing editions of 'Messiah' to be able to cite chapter and verse about how this version might differ from others. Suffice it to say that Handel didn't actually leave a definitive version and over the many years that I've heard (or sung) performances of the work, there have often been slight differences. It did not take me long to become very fond of the three solo trebles (Henry Jenkinson, Otta Jones and Robert Brooks) in their solo outings. I was taken by every single treble solo. A friend of mine says he thinks that 'He shall feed his flock' is the loveliest thing Handel ever wrote; I don't know that I'd necessarily agree with him, but I must say that Davies and Jones do a superb job with it.
As for the choir, it is magnificent. Obviously their sound is that of the English cathedral tradition and there are some who don't much care for it; I, on the other hand, admire it wholeheartedly. Higginbottom uses fairly quick tempi and the choir handles those flying semiquavers (in, for instance, 'For unto us a Child is given') with exceedingly clean technique.... Read more ›
28 of 29 people found the following review helpful
By Thomas Neal
Format:Audio CD
As an organist, chorister, choral director, composer etc, etc... I have heard and sung Messiah more times than I care to remember (and I am just 17!) My parents raised me on a healthy diet of Handel and Bach, and so over the years I have come to know and love many works by these great masters, and indeed performing a great deal in more recent years. I have heard many, many recordings of Messiah and, to put it simply, this recordings beats them all into submission. From the moment of the first few chords in the overture to the last bars of the final chorus, this is a true masterpiece of baroque performance from every angle - and I do not say that lightly. The fact that I have now started listening to Messiah for pleasure, rather than for duty or necessity, speaks for itself.
In response to Mrs Barrowman's review below, I would question all the points she has raised. Firstly, whether one is a "baroque purist" or not, this is a hugely enjoyable disc filled to the brim with technical perfection and precision. She refers to the "white sound" of the trebles - I can only think she means "pure" sound - not pure in the sense of some 1980s recordings of King's College Cambridge, which on occasions verge on being quite dry, but truly clear-cut and precise.
Furthermore, I would dispute the so-called "richness" of the female voice in other recordings. Take the venerable Helen Watts in the aria "But who may abide the day of his coming?" (an aria Helen sings superbly), and compare it to the rich clarity of Iestyn Davies in this recording, and there is no competition whatsoever (and let us not forget this is an English oratorio, not an Italian Opera, even if the composer was fluent in both styles!... Read more ›
In response to Mrs Barrowman's review below, I would question all the points she has raised. Firstly, whether one is a "baroque purist" or not, this is a hugely enjoyable disc filled to the brim with technical perfection and precision. She refers to the "white sound" of the trebles - I can only think she means "pure" sound - not pure in the sense of some 1980s recordings of King's College Cambridge, which on occasions verge on being quite dry, but truly clear-cut and precise.
Furthermore, I would dispute the so-called "richness" of the female voice in other recordings. Take the venerable Helen Watts in the aria "But who may abide the day of his coming?" (an aria Helen sings superbly), and compare it to the rich clarity of Iestyn Davies in this recording, and there is no competition whatsoever (and let us not forget this is an English oratorio, not an Italian Opera, even if the composer was fluent in both styles!... Read more ›
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful
By J. M. Burns
Format:Audio CD
I have a number of recordings of Messiah on both LP and CD, but this outstrips them all. When I returned home having purchased the recording I decided to sample one or two tracks and then listen to the full performance at a later date. I was, however, captivated from the first notes and played the entire performance from beginning to end. There is terrific energy in this version and every note sounds newly minted. The singing is first rate and the treble soloists are outstandingly good.
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful
By Marcolorenzo
TOP 1000 REVIEWER
Format:Audio CD|Amazon Verified Purchase
Fresh, spiritual, energetic, angelic, and meticulous version. This version ranks among the best versions of Messiah available. For me the reference standard is Christie's version on Harmonia Mundi, but I love this version almost as much (together with the Parrott version on Virgin). Handel - MessiahHandel: Messiah
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful
By David B
VINE™ VOICE
Format:Audio CD|Amazon Verified Purchase
The conductor's note says of this first recording of Handel's 1751 version:
"It is both a celebration of the chapel choir tradition and a window onto a particular time and place in the history of Handel's own performances of his masterpiece"
If you are used to performances or recordings of Messiah that employ large forces vocally and orchestrally, this fine recording will represent a very big change for you. Maybe you won't like it - but it's a very fine quality of performance, and very fresh on the ear. Personally I found it most enjoyable. The only bit that I felt somehow wasn't quite fulfilling was Rejoice Greatly. Not that the aria isn't sung well by the tenor here - it is - but we are so used to hearing a soprano "strutting her stuff" here, that there just seemed a little something lacking!
Overall, this is a fresh and lively performance, well worth having in your collection, especially at Naxos's price.
"It is both a celebration of the chapel choir tradition and a window onto a particular time and place in the history of Handel's own performances of his masterpiece"
If you are used to performances or recordings of Messiah that employ large forces vocally and orchestrally, this fine recording will represent a very big change for you. Maybe you won't like it - but it's a very fine quality of performance, and very fresh on the ear. Personally I found it most enjoyable. The only bit that I felt somehow wasn't quite fulfilling was Rejoice Greatly. Not that the aria isn't sung well by the tenor here - it is - but we are so used to hearing a soprano "strutting her stuff" here, that there just seemed a little something lacking!
Overall, this is a fresh and lively performance, well worth having in your collection, especially at Naxos's price.
Would you like to see more reviews about this item?
›
Go to Amazon.com to see all 22 reviews
4.7 out of 5 stars
Were these reviews helpful?
Let us know
Most Recent Customer Reviews
5.0 out of 5 stars
Unique
All male yet the sound is almost identical in passages to the normal choirs, and the enthusiasm is terrific, so lively.
Published 5 months ago by M. C. Digby
5.0 out of 5 stars
Beautiful music
Needed to listen to this before a concert.Item was delivered fast and was everything I expected
I would recommend this as a great gift
I would recommend this as a great gift
Published 6 months ago by Pauline Mitchell
5.0 out of 5 stars
A GOOD ADDITION TO MY CD LIBRARY
I bought this second-hand CD and was very favourably impressed with its condition. I love this particular version of Handel's Messiah, with boys singing the female parts, as would... Read more
Published 17 months ago by LizzyLoo
3.0 out of 5 stars
Not at all comforting
From the reviews already listed this 2006 recording by the Choir of New College Oxford and Edward Higginbottom obviously polarizes opinion, with comments from pious and pure to... Read more
Published on 19 Feb 2011 by Phillip Tolley
5.0 out of 5 stars
An excellent Messiah
A real bargain at under a fiver on the Naxos label. A fresh, well sung recording using boys' and men's voices only. Read more
Published on 29 Jan 2011 by Peter V
5.0 out of 5 stars
Easy to listen to
If you decide to buy this recording of Handel - Messiah (1751 version) by New College, Oxford you will not be disappointed and I am no expert! Read more
Published on 10 Nov 2010 by Mandy
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fabulous Messiah
This recording has brought me more pleasure than any other of The Messiah - I would recommend it to Handel 'Virgins' and stalwarts alike.
Published on 23 Dec 2009 by Mr. I. Henderson
5.0 out of 5 stars
It does what it says on the label
Having owned this for a couple of years, I was surprised at the low stars awarded by some reviewers. Read more
Published on 16 Dec 2009 by M. Donoghue
3.0 out of 5 stars
scrappy and weak
for me maybe this was underproduced or under-rehearsed
the chorus, orchestra and soloists just don't sound that prepared, and the conception is not together - the boys... Read more
the chorus, orchestra and soloists just don't sound that prepared, and the conception is not together - the boys... Read more
Published on 27 Nov 2009 by rc_rc
5.0 out of 5 stars
Magnificent
This recording is consistently fresh, not a moment sounds stale or anything other than a shining example of sound musicianship. Read more
Published on 20 April 2008 by a nice guy who likes reading
Customer Discussions
|
This product's forum
Active discussions in related forums
Search Customer Discussions
|
Related forums
|
What Other Items Do Customers Buy After Viewing This Item?
Listmania!
Feedback
- Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
