This book is awash with flash and technique but lacks the requisite warmth for an engaging read. Mr. and Mrs. Harbottle were each awarded half of Esmerelda the pig upon their divorce. Mr. Harbottle ("a horrid man with uncombed hair and dirty fingernails") wants his half served on a plate, preferably with gravy. To him, Esmeralda is just a plateful of sausage waiting to happen.
Harbottle and some young toughs steal the pig and head over to the "Pig and Whistle" pub. They lose time debating how to divide the poor pig to ensure that each former partner gets exactly half. Two kids, a dashing young policeman, and a chase through an English town later, Esmerelda escapes and the thieves are caught.
"Like the Pied (pig ) Piper she led those villains ( by the noose , as it were) across a couple of gardens...back at last full circle to her own home patch..." The linked footnote reads: "Yes, I know, 'straight and true' and 'full circle,' but somehow it feels right."
Allan Ahlberg writes some other droll humor into this elliptical story, and daughter Jessica Ahlberg captures the reader's eye with various arrows, diagrams, and other objects, and diagrams mixed into her otherwise soft illustrations. However, there's a somewhat heavy-handed approach at unconventionality--addressing the audience in the first person, self-referential statements about the book and about writing, some offbeat throwaway humor--that is geared more towards young adults than towards kids. Both the story and the bits about inserting interesting words here and there seem most appropriate for a younger audience.
This is an ambitious book that strives for innovation and modernity. At times, it succeeds. I found, however, that the author's disengaged tone and the disunity of the illustrations works against any emotional involvement with the pig, the people, or the narrative. Interesting elements are trotted out (and some people will enjoy these), but the story as a whole is subordinate to them.