Other reviewers have noticed the allegedly formulaic nature of many Reeman novels. This title, the first Reeman story I ever read, is an entertaining departure from many of the elements Reeman fans have come to expect. Along with 'A Prayer for the Ship,' this is one of my favorite Reeman books.
HMS Saracen is a monitor, a type of ship already obsolete when it was launched and now almost entirely forgotten. Nevertheless, Saracen is Richard Chesnaye's first ship, and it is aboard her that he makes a name for himself during the Gallipoli campaign. Twenty-five years later, both the ship and the man are recalled to active service during Hitler's war. And while few people are willing to say anything good about the ugly old ship, Chesnaye sees an opportunity to prove the old girl still has one more heroic act left.
Reeman's picture of the fighting at Gallipoli is dramatic and affecting, plainting in Our Hero the seeds that drive him onward during the second war. The author resists the common flaw of making his hero too messianic: Chesnaye is sympathetic, but we can see his flaws.
All in all, a highly enjoyable, read, with all the author's usual skill in depicting the horror and the glory of war at sea.