Amazon.co.uk reviews
McGuire's account of likely natural catastrophes is a splendidly integrated mechanism, relating rising tides to volcanic eruptions, eruptions to floods, global warming to local cooling--it's amazing we've lasted as long as we have (not sarcasm: fact).
Of course, the boundary between the "natural" and the "man-made" disaster is (and has been, since we arrived on the scene) a grey area. The marked success of one species threatens extinction on all. The super-success of homo sapiens bodes ill, not only for individual species, but for the whole environment.
And this, not surprisingly, is where McGuire's book starts to leave the rails. McGuire writes: "By wiping out the bulk of species that exist today, we are destroying much of the evolution's raw material and severely limiting the planet's ability to generate the species of the future." First, this is a classic piece of misdirection: we have not, as McGuire implies, destroyed the bulk of other species (although we may in the future). More important, its conclusion is plain nonsense. The mass extinction event at the end of the Palaeozoic Era (there have been four others in Earth's history already) wiped out something like 96 per cent of all species--yet life, far from being stunted, blossomed in the gaps, more various than ever before. McGuire would do better to argue that mass extinctions make room for new species to evolve! McGuire's book is a lively entertainment. But his breast-beating is hard to swallow. --Simon Ings --This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.
Product Description
About the Author
focus of the Carlton Television First Edition programme Disaster Man (February 1999), and his latest book - Apocalypse! A natural history of global disasters - was published in 1999. In 2000 he presented his own Radio 4 series on the weather and other forces of nature, and featured in two Horizon programmes as the leading British expert on volcanoes and mega-tsunami ('tidal waves'); these documentaries recorded the highest viewing figures of the year on BBC2 (6 million). --This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.