I've only previewed this but thought I'd put on file some observations:
- My initial thinking was that the compiler had done a good job in resisting the inclusion of too many obvious tracks which the hard bitten collector is bound to have, in fact on CD 2 you could say there are no obvious tracks other than the first couple - the Champs "Tequila" and Bill Justis' "Raunchy" - plus Bill Doggett's "Honky Tonk" somewhere near the end. That's not to say that some of the others aren't pretty good - Sil Austin's "Slow Walk" and the Noble Thin Man Watts (great name) track are personal faves.
- Following up that point, the well known tracks on CD 1 are all good `uns - three Duane Eddy's, Link Wray's "Rumble", some Chuck Berry instro's like "Deep Feeling", and some of the Champs' follow-up tracks and flips
- I should point out the subtitle "The Original Rock'n'Roll Recordings 1950 - 1960" in case an unwary buyer hasn't noticed it. This means that a lot of group based instros like those by the Fireballs, the Ventures and all those surf bands just don't get included. (though there is, of course, a volume 2 which advances the timeframe covered)
- CD 1 seems to be largely guitar based while CD 2 has a lot more honking saxes - this may be a deliberate "themed" separation which is explained in the compiler's notes - I understand that these come from Dave Travis so I'm sure they'll be up to his usual standard
- A good proportion of the music contained herein is rock'n'roll or that form of jump blues cum R&B which preceded it - may seem an odd statement but that isn't always the case with such sets
- Of the relatively few non rock tracks, several are attractive in their own right e.g. two tracks each of exquisite guitar picking from Chet Atkins and Merle Travis, a nice cut from Les Paul - the man who so inspired Jeff Beck - plus some country boogie cum swing from Merrill Moore
- Quite a few tracks, particularly on CD 1, are from artists who are better known as vocalists e.g. Chuck Berry, Ritchie Valens, Fats Domino, Sonny Burgess, Buddy Knox, Bill Haley, and all of these are of interest
- I was intrigued by Nino Tempo's instrumental take of Elvis' "Heartbreak Hotel" in "Heartburn Motel"
- My personal favourite out of the whole lot is Al Casey's "Ramrod"
In summary though I have to say that to an extent I do slightly share the feelings of another reviewer who thought that the title "Great Rock'n'Roll Instrumentals - Just about as good as it gets" was slightly misleading. There's no Johnny and the Hurricanes, nor are Santo and Johnny present. And perhaps the timeframe aspect should have been made more blatant in the titling - if you`re buying from Amazon or another internet supplier the wording of the subtitle is only semi-readable. However on the plus side the inclusion of some fifties material which doesn't usually make it onto anyone's release schedule does present a rare opportunity to pick up this stuff and some of it isn`t bad at all.
It nearly made five stars in my thinking and with a couple of pints or a decent bottle of wine plus the opportunity to turn the volume up might even convince me that the top rating could be justified!