Gone with the Wind [Hardcover]

 

 

Create your own review

This is a book with a thoroughly unlikable heroine; it is shot through with jaw dropping racism, so how can it qualify for four stars?

The simple answer is that it is fundamentally an absolutely ripping yarn. Margaret Mitchell's achievement is in creating a set of flawed characters, but then making the reader care about what happens to them. Couple engaging characters with a beautifully paced plot and it is easy to understand why Gone With The Wind is still in print and massively popular.

It is the story of selfish, determined daughter of a plantation, Scarlett O'Hara, her enduring love for neighbour Ashley Wilkes, his marriage to Melanie, who becomes Scarlett's devoted friend, and of course the love of Rhett Butler for Scarlett. The context of the story is the American south before, during and after the civil war. We see the relationships between the characters develop as they go from affluence, through degradation in defeat, and then rebuild.

Scarlett is of course the centre of the book and Mitchell skilfully plays with the reader's emotions towards her heroine. Basically she is selfish, spiteful, snobbish, racist, a hideously bad parent, an exploitative employer, but courageous and engaging. Initially we dislike her as a spoilt brat, her marriages are exasperating, we grow to admire her courage as she fights to survive during and after the war, she becomes a figure of ridicule as she joins the nouveau riche and finally her inability to understand Rhett's love is frustrating, infuriating and eventually tragic.

I have never seen the film, only heard the famous lines, and so was surprised to find that Rhett Butler, rather than being a heartless cad is in fact brutally honest with himself and is a strong and proud man brought low by his love for the unknowing Scarlett.

Despite the fantastic nature of the story, the epic background, the major flaw which cannot be ignored is the appalling racism. I was ready to be accepting and view the racism in the book as a portrayal rather than an espousal of the attitudes of the time. I'm afraid I can't maintain that line, Mitchell is too clearly and openly sympathetic to slavery. Her attitude is basically that slaves are subhuman, that the "good" ones prefer enslavement and that the institution was vindicated by the fact that the North perpetrated some unacceptable acts in abolishing it. Some of the sections after the civil war are just dreadful in their proslavery sentiment. It is almost unbelievable that this book was written and published in a democracy during the 20th Century. This is further illustrated by the toe curlingly embarrassing speech patterns Mitchell gives to the slave characters.

That the book can still have any validity despite this is a testament to the power of the story. The whole thing cracks along superbly with some brilliantly evocative scenes which will stick in the mind for a long time: the first time Scarlett dances with Rhett, the birth of Melanie's baby, the flight from Atlanta, Scarlet and Ashley in the Saw Mill and of course the final scene between Rhett and Scarlett.

In a strange way GWTW reminded me of the Lord of the Rings. It is not a great work of literature. It has some serious flaws, but it is an absolutely fabulous story, and it gave rise to a whole sub genre, while remaining superior to any of its successors.

So final thoughts.
-I highly recommend GWTW as a thundering good read, but be aware you'll need a strong stomach
-Don't be daunted by the size, the plot is well paced and it never drags
-It's not just a girly book, I'm an (ex) rugby playing bloke and I loved the story

All too often, when the book 'Gone With The Wind' is mentioned, people let out a groan of derision. Mostly these are people who have only seen the film. The film, although a wonderful classic, is a product of its times. Like many epics of that era, it is none too subtle. It also feels overly dramatic, no doubt the effect of cramming such a long story into a single film. The novel, however, is flawless. It may get written off as a romance in the same vein as Mills & Boon, but anyone who has read it will agree that is a most unfair comparison. It is a brilliantly researched historical drama, containing many finer points that are only discovered upon a second, or even third reading. The characters are so vividly drawn, and as the novel takes place over many years, there is real scope for development. Scarlett O'Hara is utterly believable as the flawed heroine, as is Rhett Butler, the cynical anti-hero. Ashley is symbolic of the civilisation 'gone with the wind'. But the most quietly fascinating character of all must be Melanie. The love story between Scarlett and Rhett is not so central a theme to the novel as survival and the struggle for independence. For a novel that contains such a broad scope of events and rich abundance of characters, Margaret Mitchell manages to keep a tight rein on both plot and pace. There are those books that make such a profound impression on our own lives that we never forget them - 'Gone With The Wind' is such a book.

'Gone With The Wind' amazed me. I thought it would be light, throwaway romantic fiction. Instead, it is a tough, believable, intelligent and completely gripping historical novel.

The characters are mesmerising, plausible and original - I expected more cliches, but having read it I have come to the conclusion that GWTW created the cliches because it is just so damn good!

I can really see why people still consider it the greatest historical novel ever written. The fact that it has survived the test of time, unlike the many books that are applauded as brilliant one year and forgotten the next, should give you some clue as to just how good this book is.

Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review

› See all 137 customer reviews on Amazon.co.uk

 

4.0 out of 5 stars Love it!!
I absolutely adore this book and equally did the film, if you did enjoy the film then the book is somewhat better because it offers you almost an extended version, and being so... Read more

Published 29 days ago by FanOfThings

5.0 out of 5 stars A Book I've Read Over and Over

Every woman has her Ashely and her Rhett Butler. Goes along with a line in my own book: "A woman has but two loves in life, the one who breaks her heart and the one she... Read more

Published 2 months ago by E. Newman

5.0 out of 5 stars Great read but contains one hell of a flaw
Its not hard to see why Gone with the Wind is loved by a lot of readers. Its a cracking read which has 'best seller' practically stamped all over it. Read more

Published 2 months ago by J. Willis

2.0 out of 5 stars Cheap but ok
Well it is printed on poor quality paper - but what else would you expect for this price :))))

But you would never regret if it gets dirty or stolen

(Mine... Read more

Published 2 months ago by Knight_of_light

5.0 out of 5 stars A passionate and provocative novel
Weighing in at 1011 pages, it looks like an intimidating novel, but the story rattles along at a tremendous pace, propelled by Mitchell's efficient writing style. Read more

Published 3 months ago by Stephen Citynskyj

5.0 out of 5 stars It really is a classic!
I'm in my late 20s, and I was a little apprehensive about reading this book: my Grandmother recommended it (surely not a good sign), and I'd tried to watch the 'classic' film but... Read more

Published 4 months ago by amazonian shopper

4.0 out of 5 stars A Classic!
I have just finished Gone with the Wind and I absolutely loved it in place and in other places I was totally shocked by what I was reading. Read more

Published 4 months ago by S.Duncan

4.0 out of 5 stars Gone With The Wind
This book is great and I love the story. It's very cheap considering it about 1000+ pages. When I first heard of it, I got it from the library because I wasn't sure if it was... Read more

Published 6 months ago by vampiregirl<3

5.0 out of 5 stars Brilliant Epic
GWTW is my all-time favorite book that made me a lover of literature. I first read it when I was eleven, I re-read it every couple of years, but the magic never goes away. Read more

Published 8 months ago by sonar

5.0 out of 5 stars Quite simply, the best book ever written
I believe the title of this review says it all really. I had tried to read this a few times before, and been put off by the size of the book, or the author's use of phonetic... Read more

Published 8 months ago by Diarab

Search Customer Reviews
Only search this product's reviews

› See all 137 customer reviews on Amazon.co.uk

Search Listmania!