Most Helpful Customer Reviews
82 of 87 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Which language? What's in the box?, 4 Aug 2009
Soundtracks are in English, French and German for the film discs; English only for the Bonus Disc.
Film sub-titles are English, English SDH, French, German, Danish, Swedish, Norwegian, Finnish, Dutch and Turkish.
Commentary sub-titles are: English, French and German.
Bonus disc sub-titles are: Greek, Italian, Spanish, Portuguese, Polish and Hungarian.
There are 4 discs enclosed, "including all three films and over four hours of supplemental materials".
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
85 of 91 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Masterpiece, 22 Oct 2008
Everyone seems to have reviewed the Steelbook Amazon Exclusive version of this. I actually prefer this version and it is the one I bought. For one thing I feel that cramming all the discs into one small case means that it gets lost on the shelf amidst the rest of your DVD collection. A substatntial box means that it has more of a presence up there, and also it's not AS big as the original 2001 release so it's still slim. This is due to the extremely slim individual cases, which I prefer than having all discs in one case because each story gets its own front image filling the square and nice images and synposis of each one on the back. (this is contrary to the product image above which makes the case appear as if its the same size as the 2001 release). Altogether the packaging for this is a lot fuller. I like the pictures on the front of each case, and the combination of shiny black case with blood splattering and extremely slimline black cases give the whole thing a really sleek mafia feel to it.
My only complaint would be that the box itself is probably the least durable out of the three (ie. this one, the 2001 release and the steelbook), but not if you take good care of it. As to the films themselves, this is my all-time favourite film saga. Beautifully dark and chilling and stylish. And not only that but compared to the 2001 release you are provided with the ultimate picture & sound quality and the ultimate colour giving you the ultimate film-viewing experience ever. Truly the films could not have been more restored than they are here. Also we have the joy of having Part II on only one disc, which avoids the need to get up half-way through your viewing experience to switch diss, although it's worth noting that even though it's on one disc the word 'Intermission' appears for a brief moment in between where the the two dics would have to have been swapped, which gives you an opportunity to get up and get some refreshments anyway. It would have been better if they'd have just let it carry on running (although maybe they showed it in the cinema originally with an intermission). People always slate Part III but I think that when taking the three films as an entity it serves it purpose superbly. I love all three films - and you can't love them in the same way because they are different types of films. Part I is all about introducing the family and how Vito passes on the Don mantle to Michael. Part II serves as prequel and sequel showing the Beginnings of Don Vito and how he arrived at his position at the beginning of Part I, as well as Michael's descenet deeper into sin and showing the atrocities he commits as Don Corleone. Part III then is all about the guilt, misery, regret and pain Michael feels because of his past sins and the man he's become. Part II and III are equally tragic in that you almost believe things are going to turn out all right. You're led to believe that Michael has made up with poor sweet Fredo, making his murder all the more striking. You're led to believe that after Michael's prayer next Don Tommassino's coffin that he actually will redeem himself and it will be all happy endings. Not so - and in fact the 9-hour long epic that is "The Godfather Trilogy" culminates in the most powerful film ending ever. Personally, I cannot find fault with any of the films. The ultimate film trilogy, and the ultimate restoration, with 4 hours of special features, provide the ultimate box-set.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
91 of 98 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A DVD you can't refuse, 28 Oct 2001
This review is from: The Godfather Trilogy (5 Disc Box Set) [DVD] (DVD)
The Godfather Trilogy is, as a whole, the best achievement in filmmaking that's ever happened. Brilliant stories, brilliant performances (Marlon Brando, Al Pacino, Diane Keaton, Robert Duvall and Robert De Niro stand out as excellent leads) and top class cinematography coupled with great scripts make Part I and Part II so compelling to watch. The same should be said for Part III. I don't know why people criticise it so much. Granted it's not as good as the other two, and the casting of Coppola's daughter as Mary Corleone was a stupid mistake, but as a whole I think the film is excellent, especially the climactic finale. So why people hate it so much is a mystery to me too. As for the DVD, well the picture is vastly improved. Having seen most variations of the VHS versions, I can say that they've worked hard to improve the picture and sound for the films. The extras are amazing. With many lengthy featurettes, well over an hour's worth of deleted scenes for the first two films (and an alternate beginning for Part III) plus more, it'll take ages to watch fully. So, let's see - 9 hours of the best film saga ever, with a whole host of extras - this is a DVD you can't refuse.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|