God Emperor Of Dune: The Fourth Dune Novel [Paperback]

 

 

Create your own review

I have read only the first four books of the Dune series so far, having started 'Heretics' a short while ago. This one however was the one i least enjoyed. The book essenetially revolves around Leto Atredies (the 'tyrant') and seems very flat as a result. In the other books there was at least a sense of conflict whereby Herbert would tell the story from different perspectives, but some of the philosophical ramblings of Leto leave The characters constantly asking questions that are never answered, leaving the reader's mind in tangles. Too many scenes leave the talking to Leto and they seem to disappear up his backside completely while the rest of the characters are repeatedly forced to accept how 'marvellous' he is.

However, having said that it does still contain some excellent parts: the ending, the test of Siona, and the whole Ixian 'no-room' concept are fantastic, but the book has too many flaws to be as good as the others. The fact that Dune itself is no longer Dune, but an earthlike planet destroys the majesty of the place Herbert created in the first place. But the most frustrating thing is that fantastic characters like Harq Al-Ada and Ghani from the last (best) book Children Of Dune were crying out for a book of their own. These just disappear as the story skips 3000 odd years to this date, leaving a feeling of frustration as new characters enter the fray who are, lets face it, not a patch on the first 3 books'.

A good, but -not- great offering. Writer's block, perhaps?

I know the title of the review is a cliché, but frankly it's the most apt way to sum up yet another work of genius by Frank Herbert.

The beauty of the Dune series is that it may be science fiction on its surface but it is a deep study of religion, politics and society, and this novel proves no different. The main theme in this particular instalment of the series being the blending of Religion and Government, in a far more extreme manner than even the Mentat-Emperor, Paul Muad’dib.

All the little details are there, from the esoteric technologies of the Ixians to the Face Dancers of the Bene Tleilax, and let's not forget the Bene Gessesrit. The plot itself revolves around Leto and his 'Golden Path' and those who wish to destroy it. I won't go into the plot anymore as I don't want to spoil the lavish tale which Herbert has crafted as the point of the review is to encourage you to read the book.

The writing style is exactly the same as that of the previous novels; "chapters" interspersed with musings and facts from archives and quotes from the characters. This styles allows the novel to flow without the need for proper chapters and makes for a compelling read, I literally had trouble putting this book down to get to bed.

All in all, a superb read.

God Emperor of Dune's reputation precedes it. Even in the context of a series of sequels that are generally perceived to be of lower quality than the original Dune, the fourth book in Frank Herbert's sci-fi saga still manages to distinguish itself in most people's minds as the series' plodding, self-indulgent and pretentious nadir. Certainly, it's hard to avoid the sense that Herbert is testing his readers' goodwill here, smuggling his grand statement on the workings of humanity into a mass-market sci-fi paperback with a garish cover. Nonetheless there is something undeniably appealing about God Emperor of Dune's extremism, its refusal to play to the gallery.

Leto II, who at the end of Children of Dune had accepted an irreversible and slow metamorphosis into a sandworm in order to pursue the mysterious `golden path,' is now thousands of years old, rules over the universe with meticulous despotism, and bears a more than passing physical resemblance to Jabba the Hutt. Bored and desperate for humanity to finally show itself capable of surviving on its own by escaping his prescient visions and deposing him, he is delighted to discover that the latest product of his Atreides breeding programme cannot be seen by prescience. This sets the stage for what is, essentially, a philosophical dialogue bolted awkwardly to a medieval courtly drama.

The latter provides what little plot can be found here, with a not particularly convincing love triangle between the autocratic God Emperor, a saintly young woman genetically designed to tempt Leto's increasingly diminished humanity, and the brash head of Leto's military - the latest in a long line of clones taken from the dead flesh of Duncan Idaho, the Atreides swordmaster that featured prominently in the first three books. Most of the characters are reasonably well developed - Leto himself, so unknowably dull in Children, is a particularly engaging presence here, his keenly-felt loss of humanity contrasting with a bored, arrogant despair at the short-sighted stupidity of the human race he has never truly been a part of. The character of Duncan Idaho, grappling with a loss of identity brought on by the discovery that he is merely the latest in a long line of facsimiles, is yet another example of Herbert's tremendous talent for taking worn-out sci-fi clichés and making them feel fresh, engaging and weird. Unfortunately, the character of Leto and Duncan's love interest is barely developed at all - a terrible missed opportunity, as her dilemma of choosing between spiritual, religious love and physical, human love is a powerful one that this book could have explored from an unusual perspective.

However, the meat of the book is taken up by Herbert's use of Leto as a mouthpiece through which to espouse his views on a wide range of subjects, including the nature of language, the recording of history, the boundaries between statecraft and religion, and the balance between secure autocracy and chaotic anarchy. The effect is not unlike being cornered in a pub by an intelligent, garrulous and intoxicated veteran of the counter-culture who is in the process of reconsidering his liberal stance, and the enjoyment one can derive from this book is entirely dependent on just how engaging you find the company of Leto/Frank. For what it's worth, I'd say the musings on the nature of language and its ability to lock people into certain ways of thinking are genuinely interesting, particularly when juxtaposed with the Dune series' theme of self-fulfilling prophecy. Also, it's a brave book that points out the limitations of a universe defined by words, even as it manages to express its philosophical ideas with far greater clarity than, say, the dreadful second half of Children of Dune. On the other hand, the passages on the roles of gender and homosexuality in the military struck me as ludicrously simpleminded, and there are numerous passages where Herbert fails to make his point clearly, before having Leto huff that these darned humans are just too slow on the uptake.

So, a difficult book to review. It's certainly not typical sci-fi blockbuster fare, and anyone expecting a rip-roaring adventure in the vein of Dune is likely to be disappointed. It's not exactly a rigorous work of philosophy either, consisting as it does of almost entirely unsupported and heavily generalised assertions. If, however, you've been reading the little chapter headings in the previous Dune books and thought, "I wish there were more of these," this may well be the book for you.

Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review

› See all 19 customer reviews on Amazon.co.uk

 

5.0 out of 5 stars Frank Herbert quality writing as always.
Excellent book, continuing the long history that started at Dune. Frank Herbert manages to introduce new characters as if they where there from the beginning. Read more

Published 1 month ago by elvispt

3.0 out of 5 stars A departure from the original trilogy.
Since the last hundred or so pages of Children of Dune, I have slowly seen decline in the plot of the Dune series. Read more

Published 11 months ago by Mr. Kevin Lee Sparrow

4.0 out of 5 stars "God Emperor of Dune"

It's hard to find the words for this fourth book in the original Dune series. It is strange, it is unique for the genre and stands out in the series. Read more

Published 24 months ago by David Brookes

5.0 out of 5 stars What would YOU do if you were a three-thousand-year-old, precogniscent, nigh on immortal, tad unhappy, human-sandworm hybrid?
This is my first Frank Herbert Dune novel and if I had to pinpoint the main characteristic that makes this story such a page-turner, I'd probably have to highlight the structure... Read more

Published on 1 Oct 2009 by Fantasy Lore

1.0 out of 5 stars I want to give it no stars but cant.
It took me a year to get round to reading the whole of this book.

Usually it takes me a week at the most to read a decent length book like this is. Read more

Published on 15 Jun 2009 by L. wales

2.0 out of 5 stars Intriguing but a little tedious.
The premise of this book, with the character from the last Dune book evolving into a different creature entirely, and knowing not only the future but having senses that allow him... Read more

Published on 2 Jun 2009 by Mr. M. Jones

4.0 out of 5 stars Dune Book 4
This 4th novel in Frank Herbert's Dune series is curious, in that it is simultaneously a radical departure from the previous novels while still retaining many familiar elements... Read more

Published on 4 April 2006 by Jane Aland

4.0 out of 5 stars Profound - but a little too long
This part of the series has some fundamental revelations in the future development of the universe created in the mind of Frank Herbert. Read more

Published on 24 Jun 2004 by Daniel J. Staple

3.0 out of 5 stars A series you just can't give up on
This is a strange little book, and marks something of a metamorphosis rather like than experience by Leto in the novel: Frank Herbert's Dune novels change dramatically through the... Read more

Published on 19 May 2004

2.0 out of 5 stars good for hardcore Dune fans, but not for the casual reader
Set three thousand years after the events in Children of Dune we see that the plans laid out in the first book by Dr. Read more

Published on 17 Feb 2004

Search Customer Reviews
Only search this product's reviews

› See all 19 customer reviews on Amazon.co.uk

Search Listmania!