Even before his shocking, violent and untimely death John Lennon was always regarded as a much more enigmatic and fascinating figure than Paul McCartney. One reason for this was to do with his personality, but he was also far less prolific. As a solo artist Lennon only released seven studio albums in ten years, and one of these was an album of covers. There was also a five year gap between the Rock and Roll album and the final album Double Fantasy. So in the second half of the seventies he actually only released two albums. Okay there was the posthumous Milk and Honey and of course a few non album singles which artist regularly released in those days, but this is still far from prolific. In that same period McCartney issued about ten albums and many more since. Of course there is no knowing if Lennon would have gone on to become more prolific once again had he lived.
A fascinating game for rock fans is to estimate whether either of the main Beatles would have been regarded as the great geniuses they are considered to be had they been measured on their solo work only. As this is a Lennon review I will just concentrate on his work. Whether he has produced better solo music than McCartney is difficult to compare, however I think because he wasn't so prolific he was usually at least more interesting. I also believe both produced their fair share of rubbish, more so Macca simply because he was more prolific. Certainly the almost immaculate quality control exercised by the Beatles throughout their career (perhaps with the help of George Martin) was no longer evident in either of Lennon-McCartney solo careers.
I compiled a list of truly great Beatles songs composed by Lennon: Hard Days Night, If I Fell, Help, Norwegian Wood, Nowhere Man, Girl, In My Life, I'm Only Sleeping, Strawberry Fields Forever, Lucy In The Sky, A Day In The Life. There probably aren't that many more great ones, although of course there are loads more good songs. I would suggest Macca had about as many great songs. However it is noticeable that most of Lennon's best songs come in the first half of the Beatles career; only the last three coming after 66 and none after 67, whereas McCartney's classics were spread more evenly throughout the Beatles career, and by the end there was little doubt he'd surpassed Lennon as a composer. Lennon's supporters would argue that this was because Johnny had lost interest in the Fabs, so it is from this point we come to his solo career.
If we are to list his truly classic solo songs as I did with his Beatles work then what do we have? Imagine, definitely but then what else? I would suggest Jealous Guy and Mind Games, both of which I believe actually have better tunes than Imagine, but it is the lyrics of Imagine as much as the music which have helped it achieve classic status. I would also add Happy Xmas War Is Over (one of the best Christmas Songs ever written) to the list, but after that we are struggling. Instant Karma, Power To The People, Whatever Gets You Thru The Night, No 9 Dream, Starting Over and Watching The Wheels are all good singles, but I wouldn't call any of them truly classic songs; whilst I've never liked the tune of Woman, which I've always thought a bit of a bland dirge, only achieving the huge success it did because of its time of release. I actually much prefer Beautiful Boy which is a lovely tune and not far off being included in his list of classics. I do like Cold Turkey, but it's not a classic song, nor even a good single, whilst Give Peace a Chance is a great sentiment and can be moving in certain circumstances, but it's not even a good song. Moving on to the album tracks, How Do You Sleep, the notorious attack on McCartney, is actually a good song, although some people might be put off by the lyrics. I also particularly like Crippled Inside and You Are Here, and both God and Working Class Hero are at least interesting.
This is the first definitive box set of Lennon's released solo work. There was the earlier four disc set, but that contained much unreleased stuff. This set contains virtually all the solo Lennon most people would want and is an excellent compromise between the skimpy fifteen track hits disc and the overpriced Signature box of all the albums which have been released simultaneously. However if you really only want the truly best solo Lennon you'd be better sticking with the earlier two disc Working Class Hero.
So what do you get here?
You get all of Plastic Ono Band; all of Imagine apart from one track, (It's So Hard, which is actually a good bluesy track); just three tracks from the heavily criticised Sometime In New York City - the two most famous songs New York City (a good rocker) and the controversial Woman is the Nigger of the World (as bad as it sounds). There is also Sunday Bloody Sunday which I'd never heard properly before. The verses of this make a good rock song, but the chorus is irritating and the lyrics would annoy and even antagonise many English people, showing Lennon at his worst. More than half of Mind Games and nearly all of Walls and Bridges are included. There is also most of Double Fantasy and the best tracks from Milk and Honey, whilst the entire Rock and Roll album is featured.
The set is structured thematically rather than chronologically. I prefer the latter, but the thematic approach works quite well here. The Rock and Roll album is given one disc, however it doesn't follow the running order of the original album and has many other tracks interspersed. As I bought the original vinyl album not long after it was originally released, it being one of my most played albums for years, I was incredibly familiar with the original running order, and to have it disrupted now sounds weird.
The set comes in a small cardboard slip case - the kind associated with budget releases - although there is a booklet with pictures and liner notes. To be honest these aren't brilliant, and it's annoying that, although full publishing credits are given, it doesn't tell you which album each song comes from, nor even the year of release; the box set does have a low budget feel even though it is full price. Furthermore the cardboard slip cases that house the individual discs have a tendency to scratch them if you're not careful.
As I say this is ultimately all the solo Lennon most listeners would want, and if they'd have added a fifth disc it would have virtually included all the originally released material. Providing you're not bothered about original artwork and the integrity of the original running order then this is certainly worth buying rather than the original albums.
Finally, it is easy to forget that even if he wasn't quite a genius songwriter as a solo artist, John Lennon was probably the greatest rock and roll singer Britain has ever produced.