Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A tribute , to the Mother and daughter writing partnership, 30 Dec 2003
What a refreshing, enlightening and, unexpectedly, emotional experience, reading, 'The Ghost in the Little House House: A Life of Rose Wilder Lane', was. The biographical perspective, by William Holtz, showed a sensitivity and understanding towards Rose and her moods. Based on Rose's prolific letters and Diary entries, especially those pertaining to her Mother, which are publised in this book for all to read for themselves, has lead, Mr Holtz, to perceive a 'cool', exploitative relationship by Laura of Rose. The dynamics in their Mother and daughter relationship was facinating and immensly interesting but I would understand, if some of, Laura Ingalls Wilder, fans reading this book, being upset. Mr Holtz, didn't give, Laura's, perspective to the events that Rose described in her writings of her Mother, but, this may not have been possible as it was Rose who wrote about her feelings and left a detailed account of her emotional experiences in life and not her Mother. To me, it is no insult to Laura's memory by Mr Holtz's suggestion that Rose helped to get the books published by heavily editing, the stories, giving artistic expression when needed. Surely, Rose wanted to help her mother become financially secure and writing creatively is what she did best. In all, this book is recommended reading, especially for those who like primary evidence of Diaries and Letters. Just wish we can have more details on why Laura used manipulation, rather than openess, when communicating with Rose. Perhaps there is a book some where explaining their Mother-daughter relationship more fully.
|
|
|
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Co-author or fine editor?, 17 Nov 1998
By A Customer
While I very much enjoyed reading this biography about Rose and reading excerpts of her own well crafted writing, this book disturbed me. The author of "Ghost" repeatedly tried to assert the merit of his own book by discrediting Mrs. Wilder's talent and character. He didn't need to. "Ghost" is a fine biography of a complex women in its own right. It seems to me that Rose's role in the Little House books was that of a skilled editor. I wouldn't deny that she had a crucial role, but to insinuate that she was somehow cheated out of her just billing as co-author seems overly sensational. Having read works attributed both to Mrs. Wilder and to Mrs. Lane, I see distinct differences in style. Rose's work is sophisiticated and crafted. Laura was a gifted storyteller. Both were strong, admirable women. Each in her own way paid a high price for her independent nature, and each in her own way made a significant contribution to literature. They competed enough in life; I would have preferred that author of "Ghost" not extend that competition into their legacies as well.
|
|
|
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
The only book I have ever been unable to finish, 27 Jun 1998
By A Customer
I was thrilled to have found a book on Rose Wilder Lane in the public library as I had always wondered what happened to her after she grew up. Mr. Holtz' style made me sorry I went looking. It is painstakingly well researched indeed, as one other reader noted, but the emphasis is on the pain. I was extrememly interested in the subject matter, but the writer's need to write this BIOGRAPHY as if it were a research paper to be graded on accuracy put me off. It is quite a long book, and I'm sorry to say that just slightly before I made it half-way through I had to say "enough". The prose is rather staid, uninteresting and more like a textbook. I appreciate the fact that the research was done properly and well, but the footnotes were distracting and really should have been left out. I have never ever left a book half-finished before or since.I found it rather ironic to say the least that this story of a woman who spent much of her life making her mother's writings more interesting should have been documented in so boring a manner.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|